Measuring nearshore waves at break point in 4D with Stereo-GoPro photogrammetry: A field comparison with multi-beam LiDAR and pressure sensors

Abstract

Measuring nearshore waves remains technically challenging despite wave properties are being used in a variety of applications. With the promise of high-resolution and remotely-sensed measurements of water surfaces in four dimensions (spatially and temporally), stereo-photogrammetry applied to video imagery has grown as a viable solution over the last ten years. However, past deployments have essentially used costly cameras and optics, requiring fixed deployment platforms and hindering the applicability of the method in the field.Focusing on close-range measurements of nearshore waves at break point, this paper presents a detailed evaluation of a field-oriented and cost-effective stereo-video system composed of two GoProTM(Hero 7) cameras capable of collecting 12-megapixel imagery at 24 frames per second. The so-called ‘Stereo-GoPro’ system was deployed in the surf zone during energetic conditions at a macrotidal field site using a custom-assembled mobile tower. Deployed concurrently with stereo-video, a 16-beam LiDAR (Light Detection and Ranging) and two pressure sensors provided independent data to assess stereo-GoPro performance. All three methods were compared with respect to the evolution of the free-surface elevation over 25 min of recording at high tide and the wave parameters derived from spectral analysis. We show that stereo-GoPro allows producing digital elevation models (DEMs) of the water surface over large areas (250 m2) at high spatial resolution (0.2 m grid size), which was unsurpassed by the LiDAR. From instrument inter-comparisons at the location of the pressure transducers, free-surface elevation root-mean square errors of 0.11 m and 0.18 m were obtained respectively for LiDAR and stereo-GoPro. This translated into a maximum relative error of 3.9% and 12.5% on spectral wave parameters for LiDAR and stereo-GoPro, respectively. Optical distortion in imagery, which could not be completely corrected with calibration, was the main source of error. Whilst stereo-video processing workflow remains complex, cost-effective stereo-photogrammetry already opens new opportunities for deriving wave parameters in coastal regions, as well as for various other practical applications. Further tests should try to address specifically challenges associated to variable ambient conditions and acquisition configurations, affecting measurement performance, to guarantee a larger uptake of the technique.