Machine-Learning Techniques Can Enhance Dairy Cow Estrus Detection Using Location and Acceleration Data.

Jun Wang,Matt Bell,Gang Liu,Xiaohang Liu

doi:10.3390/ani10071160

Abstract

Simple SummaryWe investigated the feasibility of combing location, acceleration, and machine learning technologies to accurately detect dairy cows in estrus. An automatic data acquisition system was developed to continuously monitor the location and acceleration data of cow activities. Estrus indicators were obtained by principal component analysis (PCA) of twelve behavioral metrics generated from the collected data sets, which were: duration of standing, duration of lying, duration of walking, duration of feeding, duration of drinking, switching times between activity and lying, steps, displacement, average velocity, walking times, feeding times, drinking times. We introduced K-nearest neighbor (KNN), back-propagation neural network (BPNN), linear discriminant analysis (LDA), classification and regression tree (CART) algorithms for the estrus identification of cows. A comparative assessment of the integration of algorithms and time windows was performed to for determining the optimal combination. The results achieving in this study suggest that synthesis of location, acceleration, and machine learning methods can be utilized to improve estrus cow detection.The aim of this study was to assess combining location, acceleration and machine learning technologies to detect estrus in dairy cows. Data were obtained from 12 cows, which were monitored continuously for 12 days. A neck mounted device collected 25,684 records for location and acceleration. Four machine-learning approaches were tested (K-nearest neighbor (KNN), back-propagation neural network (BPNN), linear discriminant analysis (LDA), and classification and regression tree (CART)) to automatically identify cows in estrus from estrus indicators determined by principal component analysis (PCA) of twelve behavioral metrics, which were: duration of standing, duration of lying, duration of walking, duration of feeding, duration of drinking, switching times between activity and lying, steps, displacement, average velocity, walking times, feeding times, and drinking times. The study showed that the neck tag had a static and dynamic positioning accuracy of 0.25 ± 0.06 m and 0.45 ± 0.15 m, respectively. In the 0.5-h, 1-h, and 1.5-h time windows, the machine learning approaches ranged from 73.3 to 99.4% for sensitivity, from 50 to 85.7% for specificity, from 77.8 to 95.8% for precision, from 55.6 to 93.7% for negative predictive value (NPV), from 72.7 to 95.4% for accuracy, and from 78.6 to 97.5% for F1 score. We found that the BPNN algorithm with 0.5-h time window was the best predictor of estrus in dairy cows. Based on these results, the integration of location, acceleration, and machine learning methods can improve dairy cow estrus detection.

Highlights

In mammals, estrus is a behavioral sign that ensures that the female is ready to be mated close to the time of ovulation [1,2]
By eliminating the unreliable data which accounted for about 4.3% of the sets of planimetric location errors, the average of maximum errors and mean location errors changed to 0.425 m and 0.2467 m, respectively
Measurements of location and acceleration information obtained with the neck tag proved to be acceptable for the conditions of this study when cows were housed in the barn

Summary

Introduction

Estrus is a behavioral sign that ensures that the female is ready to be mated close to the time of ovulation [1,2]. Standing estrus is often defined as true estrus, when the cow makes no effort to escape when mounted by other cows. Other signs of estrus include mounting of other cows, increased activity, and mucous discharge from the vulva. While standing to be mounted is recognized as the primary behavioral sign of estrus, other behaviors, such as anogenital sniffing, restlessness, bellowing, chin resting, head mounting, and an attempt to mount are considered secondary symptoms [3]. Progesterone measurement in plasma or milk can aid detection of estrus by determining error in other detection methods, such as false positives when using activity [4]. The online monitoring device of progesterone concentration is available, it does not fit for these commercial farms highly concerned about profit rates due to the equipment cost and expense of chemicals used per measurement

Objectives

Results

Discussion

Conclusion