Luck's mischief: obligation and blameworthiness on a thread

Abstract

Acknowledgments 1. Luck's Hijacking of Obligation and Responsibility 1.1. Luck's Threat to Obligation and Responsibility 1.2. Synopsis 2. Obligation and Alternative Possibilities 2.1. Luck 2.2. Obligation and Alternatives 2.3. Stage-Setting for Objections: Frankfurt Examples 3. Obligation Presupposes Alternatives: A Defense 3.1. Nelkin on a Novel Interpretation of OIC 3.2. An Argument from Frankfurt Examples 3.2.1. Frankfurt Examples and Kant's Law 3.2.2. Frankfurt Examples and Action 3.2.3. Frankfurt Examples and Specific versus General Abilities 3.2.4. Does Blameworthiness Require Impermissibility? 3.3. Truth and the Function of Judgments 3.4. Graham on Kant's Law 3.5. Pereboom's Objections 4. Obligation under Threat 4.1. Frankfurt Examples, Luck, and Obligation 4.2. Principle Motivation/Ability 4.3. Diminished Obligation 4.4. Objections and Replies 4.5. Another Frankfurt Example 4.6. Obligation and Self-Control 5. Blameworthiness under Threat 5.1. Blameworthiness and Impermissibility 5.1.1. The Objective View 5.1.2. The Simple Subjective View 5.1.3. The Complex Subjective View 5.2. Respecting Subjective Views 5.2.1. Subjective Views Defended 5.2.2. Subjective Views and the Principle of Alternative Expectations 5.3. Diminished Blameworthiness 5.4. Changing Obligations, Blameworthiness, and Impermissibility 5.5. A Costly Way Out: Obligation and Blameworthiness Rescued 5.6. Semi-Compatibilism and Non-Moral Varieties of Blameworthiness 5.6.1. Semicompatibilism 5.6.2. Semicompatibilism's Domain 5.6.3. The Scope of Non-Moral Varieties of Blameworthiness 5.7. Teleological Theories, Obligation, and Blameworthiness 6. Ramifications 6.1 Character, Obligation, and Blameworthiness 6.2. On the Moral Aims of Education 6.3. Imperiled Aims 7. Some Thoughts on the Metaphysics of Free Will 7.1. Constrained Skepticism 7.2. Frankfurt Examples and Guidance Control 7.3. From the Frying Pan into the Fire: Frankfurt Examples Yet Again 7.4. The Traditional Dilemma 7.4.1. Determinism, Obligation, and Blameworthiness 7.4.2. Indeterminism, Obligation, and Blameworthiness 7.4.3. A Slight Digression: Compatibilism and Luck 7.5. Our Morally Messy World Bibliography Index