Lower dimer impurity incorporation may result in higher perfection of HEWL crystals grown in microgravity: A case study

Abstract

Crystals of tetragonal hen egg white lysozyme (HEWL) grown on a series of space missions and their terrestrial counterparts were analyzed by gel electrophoresis and X-ray diffraction. The crystals were produced by vapor-diffusion and dialysis methods. The microgravity and terrestrial grown HEWL crystals were found to have effective partitioning coefficients ( K eff) for an oxidatively formed covalent dimer impurity (MW 28 K) of 2 and 9, respectively, i.e. the latter contain 4.5 times more dimers. The microgravity grown crystals allowed the collection of 24% more useful reflections and improved the resolution from 1.6 to 1.35 Å. Other improvements were also noted including lower isotropic B-factors of 16.9, versus 23.8 Å 2 for their terrestrial counterparts. High-resolution laser interferometry was applied quantitatively to evaluate the influence of dimer impurity on growth kinetics. It is shown that the growth of the (1 0 1) face from solution into which 1% dimers were introduced decelerates with increasing solution flow rate and the growth stops at a flow rate of about 0.2 mm/s. This effect occurs faster than in ultrapure solutions. The covalently bound dimers essentially increase the amplitudes of the striation-inducing growth rate fluctuations. The effect is ascribed to the enhanced transport of growth inhibiting HEWL dimer to the interface. Theoretical analysis shows that a stagnant solution around a growing crystal is strongly depleted with respect to impurity by about 60% for the measured growth parameters as compared to the solution bulk. Thus, a crystal in microgravity grows from essentially purer solution than the ones in the presence of convection flows. Therefore, it traps less stress inducing impurity and should be more perfect. For crystal/impurity systems where K eff is small enough microgravity should have an opposite effect.