Long-term effects of stand density management and genotype on wood properties of loblolly pine (Pinus taeda L.) in the mid-South USA

Abstract

Changes in ownership and forest product use patterns have incentivized growing loblolly pine (Pinus taeda L.) for chip-and-saw and sawtimber in shorter rotations in the southeastern United States. These management objectives can be accomplished by relatively low stand densities and moving fast-growing genotypes from the Atlantic Coastal Plain to other regions of the loblolly pine range, but wood quality concerns accompany these silvicultural options. In three trials in the Western Gulf region of the mid-South United States, effects of stand density management options on key wood properties (specific gravity, corewood (juvenile wood) diameter, corewood proportion, latewood proportion, corewood:outerwood (juvenile wood:mature wood) transition age as determined using specific gravity) were tested. At one site, clearwood modulus of elasticity (MOE) and modulus of rupture (MOR) were measured. Genotypes of Atlantic Coastal Plain and Western Gulf origin were also tested at two sites. In a trial in which stand density was managed at diverse levels through sequential thinning, beginning at precommercial size, only a regime that was commercially thinned to half its density two times from 297 TPH at age 7 to 62 TPH by age 41 had significant reductions in MOE, MOR, and specific gravity. Corewood diameter increased with decreasing planting density at two sites at the northwestern edge of the loblolly pine range, but corewood proportion declined with decreasing planting density due to greater diameter growth and earlier transition from corewood to outerwood. Specific gravity differences among planting densities was site-specific, with no differences at the more well-drained site. Latewood proportion, which was greater at higher planting densities, was more strongly correlated with specific gravity differences among planting densities. A planting density between 1075 and 1680 TPH would likely be optimum for these site conditions for balancing tree volume growth with minimizing reductions in specific gravity associated with reduced latewood proportion and larger corewood size. The Atlantic Coastal Plain genotype retained its tendencies to transition to outerwood earlier and have greater latewood proportions relative to a local genotype when planted at these Western Gulf sites, and its specific gravity was similar to that of the local genotype. Together these trials suggest that forest managers have flexibility in managing loblolly pine stand density without altering wood properties. Furthermore, these results provide some evidence that moving genotypes may not carry a risk of reduced wood specific gravity.