Limb Alignment Improves with Computer-Assisted Navigation in Total Knee Replacement, But Questions Remain

Abstract

The value of intraoperative computer navigation during total knee arthroplasty has been debated for more than a decade. Despite substantial research, contradictory results and reservations about the cost and efficacy of the technology have contributed to the failure of computer navigation to become the accepted standard for establishing limb alignment during knee replacement surgery. In their paper, Zhang and colleagues report the results of a well-designed, prospective, randomized study that was conducted to compare the short-term clinical and radiographic results of total knee arthroplasty performed with computer navigation with the results of total knee arthroplasty performed with conventional mechanical instruments. The authors attempted to control for as many variables as possible by studying patients with bilateral knee arthritis who were undergoing simultaneous bilateral knee replacement. For each patient, both the order of the surgery and the knee that was assigned to the computer-navigation group were selected by randomization. During the follow-up period, the clinician, radiologist, and patient were blinded with regard to the type of procedure that had been performed on each knee. The outcomes recorded included overall limb alignment on full-length radiographs; various parameters of prosthetic positioning on both standard radiographs and …