Lead bioaccessibility and commonly measured soil characteristics in Detroit, Michigan

Abstract

Historical and contemporary use of lead (Pb) in gasoline, paints, and industry have led to its concentration in urban soils, presenting a human health risk, with disproportionate impacts on children living in urban areas. Contaminated soil is one of the major contributors to child Pb exposure. While many residents practicing urban agriculture have their soil tested to determine the amount of soil total Pb present, this measure does not provide a direct indicator of soil Pb bioaccessibility (used to predict bioavailability). Because bioavailability is ultimately necessary to determine the exposure risk, we aimed to gain a more refined understanding of Pb risk using measurements commonly performed as part of typical agricultural soil tests. Accordingly, we sampled soils from 142 residential parcels located in Detroit, MI. Soils were evaluated for: pH, organic matter content, cation exchange capacity, phosphorus, sulfur, calcium, potassium, magnesium, and sodium and total and in-vitro bioaccessible (IVBA) Pb. Detroit soil IVBA Pb ranged from 4.5% to 81%, with a mean of 39%. Total Pb, organic matter (OM) content and soil pH were found to be the most important predictors of Pb bioaccessibility. Soils typically had a relatively low OM content (mean of 5%) however, samples with higher OM content had lower IVBA (e.g., the IVBA was 15.2% smaller in soils with 7.5% OM). Soils were typically slightly basic (mean of 7.8); however, samples with pH closer to neutral had lower IVBA (e.g., the IVBA was 11.6% smaller in soils with a pH of 7.3). The proximity of soil sampling locations to former smelter locations was also found to influence Pb bioaccessibility, with samples closer to former Pb smelter sites having a somewhat higher average IVBA. Results suggest increasing soil OM content in urban soils will reduce Pb bioaccessibility. Building soil OM would therefore improve both soil fertility and decrease soil Pb bioaccessibility, imparting a predicted decrease in exposure risks.