Lack-of-Fit Tests in Semiparametric Mixed Models

Abstract

In this paper we obtain the asymptotic distribution of restricted likelihood ratio tests in mixed linear models with a fixed and finite number of random effects. We explain why for such models the often quoted 50:50 mixture of a chi-s quared random variable with one degree of freedom and a point mass at zero does not hold. Our motivation is a study of the use of wavelets for lack-of-fit testing within a mixed model framework. Even though wavelet shave received a lot of attention in the last say 15 years for the estimation of piecewise smooth functions, much less is known about their ability to check the adequacy of a parametric model when fitting the observed data. In particular we study the testing power of wavelets for testing a hypothesized parametric model within a mixed model framework. Experimental results show that in several situations the wavelet-based test significantly outperforms the com-petitor based on penalized regression splines. The obtained results are also applicable for testing in mixed models in general, and shed some new insight into previous results.