Is nonvascularized autografting in the proximal scaphoid nonunions ineffective?

Abstract

In this study, we aimed to evaluate the results of proximal scaphoid non-union treated with non-vascularized bone grafting and screw fixation. Thirteen patients who were treated surgically for proximal scaphoid non-union with a minimum of one-year follow-up in our clinic were evaluated. Wrist movements were measured by standard goniometry and muscle strength by hand dynamometry. Non-union was classified radiologically according to the Schernberg classification, while functional assessment was performed based on the Herbert-Fisher Grading System and the Mayo Clinic Modified Wrist Scoring System. The mean follow-up period was 14 months (range, 12 to 40 months). Full union was observed in eight of 13 patients (61.5%). The mean time to union was 16 (range, 12 to 40) weeks. There was no loss of function of more than 10% compared to the healthy hand in the cases with full union. Postoperative mean grip strength was 37.3±3.0 kg. The rates of excellent and good results were 61.5%, moderate and poor results were 38.5% according to the Herbert-Fisher classification and the mean Mayo score was 80±13. We obtained no satisfactory results in patients treated with non-vascularized bone grafting and screw fixation for proximal scaphoid non-unions. We suggest that grafting should be carried out in selected cases due to the adverse effects of open techniques and bone grafting on vascularity of scaphoid bone.