Is Bigger Better? Evaluation of Size‐Selective Predation on Age‐0 Walleye

Abstract

AbstractThe success of fish stocking programs is dependent on poststocking survival. However, survival can be influenced by size‐selective mortality, where larger individuals are expected to be less vulnerable to predation. Walleye Sander vitreus is a commonly stocked sport fish, but little is known regarding the role of size‐selective predation on age‐0 Walleye (90–290 mm TL) that are stocked in the presence of various piscivores with different foraging strategies and morphological features. Our objective was to evaluate whether the TL of consumed age‐0 Walleye was related to predator TL, predator gape height, or the probability of predation. We also assessed whether length distributions varied among stocked, recaptured, and consumed age‐0 Walleye. Data for the food habits of Largemouth Bass Micropterus salmoides, Smallmouth Bass M. dolomieu, Northern Pike Esox lucius, adult Walleye, and Muskellunge Esox masquinongy were collected from East Okoboji Lake and West Okoboji Lake, Iowa, USA during fall 2015–2017. Over the course of the study, 301 age‐0 Walleye were recovered from 3,514 predator stomachs. Mean, maximum (85th percentile), and minimum (15th percentile) TL of the consumed age‐0 Walleye were not related to the TL or gape height of the predators (P > 0.05), but the probability of predation decreased by 0.02 for every 10‐mm increase in the TL of the age‐0 Walleye. The length distributions indicated that consumed Walleye were generally smaller, whereas recaptured Walleye tended to be larger than stocked fish were. Our approach to evaluating poststocking size‐selective predation on age‐0 Walleye furthers the current understanding of the importance of size at stocking relative to stocking success and suggests that stocking Walleye > 220 mm is economically advantageous for reducing predation risk.