Interrogating the pill: Rising distrust and the reshaping of health risk perceptions in the social media age

Abstract

Since its introduction in 1960, the combined oral contraceptive pill has become the dominant reversible contraceptive technology for controlling female fertility in spite of early and ongoing ethical, critical medical, and societal disapproval. Over the last decade, prescription rates among young women in Western Europe have declined alongside the rise of social media use. This article investigates the mechanisms underlying this change in contraceptive choices and the role played by social media in this trend. Via exploratory online observation and an in-depth interview study with 19 informants in Germany and Denmark, we find social media consolidates the social construction of hazards associated with the contraceptive pill by reshaping young women's risk perception from questions around drug reliability and safety to those of individual physical, mental, and social well-being. We shed light on how social media contributes to the delegitimation of health professionals such as gynaecologists and general practitioners and adds to wider debates on the erosion of medical authority and the attendant rise of peer influencers. We condense our findings into a framework for health-related attitude formation and decision-making in the social media age, which elucidates how social media amplifies and reshapes societal discourses regarding health-related technologies, choices, and risks.