Influence of Aspect Ratios on the Creep Behaviour of Articular Cartilage in Indentation

Abstract

Indentation tests are commonly used to determine the mechanical behaviour of articular cartilage with varying properties, thickness, and geometry. This investigation evaluated the effect of changing geometric parameters on the properties determined from creep indentation tests. Finite element analyses simulated the indentation behaviour of two models, an excised cylindrical specimen of cartilage with either normal and repair qualities and an osteochondral defect represented as a cylindrical region of repair cartilage integrated with a surrounding layer of normal tissue. For each model, the ratios of indenter radius to cartilage height and cartilage radius to indenter radius were varied. The vertical displacement of the cartilage under the indenter obtained through finite element analysis was fitted to a numerical algorithm to determine the aggregate modulus, permeability, and Poisson's ratio. Indentation behaviours of cartilage specimens for either model with were not affected by for values of 2 and 5. Aggregate modulus was not greatly affected by the geometric changes studied. Permeability was affected by changes in the ratio of specimen to indenter radii for These findings suggest that experimental configurations of excised cylindrical specimens, also representing osteochondral defects with no or unknown degree of integration, where the cartilage layer has should not have r/a values on the order of 2 for confidence in the mechanical properties determined. Indentation of osteochondral defects where the repair cartilage is fully integrated to the surrounding cartilage can be performed with confidence for all cases tested.