Improvements in Therapy Experience With Evoked Compound Action Potential Controlled, Closed-Loop Spinal Cord Stimulation—Primary Outcome of the ECHO-MAC Randomized Clinical Trial

Abstract

Spinal cord stimulation (SCS) is a well-established treatment for chronic neuropathic pain. However, over- or underdelivery of the SCS may occur because the spacing between the stimulating electrodes and the spinal cord is not fixed; spacing changes with motion and postural shifts may result in variable delivery of the SCS dose and, in turn, a suboptimal therapy experience for the patient. The evoked compound action potential (ECAP)—a measure of neural activation—may be used as a control signal to adapt SCS parameters in real time to compensate for this variability. In this prospective, multicenter, randomized, single-blind, crossover trial, reduction in overstimulation intensity was used as a perceptual measure to evaluate a novel ECAP-controlled, closed-loop (CL) SCS algorithm relative to traditional open-loop (OL) SCS. The primary outcome used a Likert scale to assess sensation during activities of daily living with CL versus OL SCS. Of the 42 subjects in the intent-to-treat analysis set, 97.6% had a reduction in sensation with CL versus OL SCS. The primary objective was met as the lower confidence limit (87.4%) exceeded the performance goal of 50% (P < .001). A total of 88.1% (37/42) of subjects preferred CL and 11.9% (5/42) preferred OL SCS. SCS dose consistency during CL SCS was demonstrated by the reduced variability in ECAP amplitude with CL SCS (standard deviation: 8.72 µV) relative to OL SCS (standard deviation: 19.95 µV). Together, these results demonstrate that the ECAP-controlled, CL algorithm reduces or eliminates unwanted sensation, and thereby provides a more preferred and consistent SCS experience. PerspectivePatients with chronic pain need durable and dependable options for pain relief. SCS is an important therapy option, and new technology advancements could improve long-term therapy use. CL SCS offers a preferred and more consistent therapy experience for patients that could lead to increased therapy utilization and reliable therapy outcomes.