Impact of scapula anatomical landmark positioning on scapular orientation using CT-based 3-dimensional models: an intraobserver repeatability and interobserver reproducibility study

Abstract

HypothesisThe primary objective of this study was to assess intra-observer repeatability and inter-observer reproducibility of the 3D coordinates of a set of scapula anatomical landmarks obtained by manual positioning on conventional supine CT-scan based scapula surface models. The secondary objective was to assess intra-observer repeatability and inter-observer reproducibility of the resulting 3D scapular orientation. It was hypothesized that the 3D scapular orientation reliability would be better or similar than established reliability of intra-operative baseplate positioning (i.e. version and inclination) in reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (rTSA). MethodsThree anatomical landmarks, i.e. acromial angle (AA), inferior angle (IA), and trigonum scapulae (TS), were manually positioned on 81 scapula surface models using updated landmark definitions. These models were obtained by the segmentation of CT-scan images acquired from patients undergoing elective rTSA procedures at the Department of Surgery at Geneva University Hospitals between May 2022 and December 2023. This procedure was repeated 3 times per scapula by 3 independent observers. A set of parameters corresponding to the 3D landmark coordinates (expressed in an average scapula coordinate system) and the 3D scapular orientation (expressed as three angles related to the retraction/protraction, lateral/medial rotation, and internal/external rotation) were computed. Intra-observer repeatability and inter-observer reproducibility were assessed for each of these parameters using an intra-class correlation as a relative reliability metric. Standard error of measurement (SEM) was also reported as an absolute reliability metric. ResultsIntra-observer ICC and inter-observer ICC ranged from poor to moderate for AA, poor to excellent for IA, and poor to excellent for TS. However, low SEM, ranging from 0.4 mm to 2.4 mm for intra-observer repeatability and from 0.2 mm to 1.8 mm for inter-observer reproducibility, were obtained for every coordinate of each anatomical landmark. This results in poor to moderate intra-observer ICC and inter-observer ICC for scapula angular orientation. Again, low SEM, ranging from 0.4° to 0.8° for intra-observer repeatability and 0.4° to 0.6° for inter-observer reproducibility, were obtained, arguing for reliable measurements. Discussion and ConclusionThis study demonstrates that manual positioning of the three scapula anatomical landmarks recommended by the International Society of Biomechanics can be performed in a reliable manner across measures and observers on surface bone models obtained from CT-scan images. However, a clear and standardized definition of these landmarks is needed to ensure consistency across measurements.