Impact of Fetal Echocardiography Comprehensiveness on Diagnostic Accuracy

Abstract

Fetal echocardiography is a major diagnostic imaging modality for prenatal detection of critical congenital heart disease. Diagnostic accuracy is essential for appropriate planning of delivery and neonatal care. The relationship between study comprehensiveness and diagnostic error is not well understood. The aim of this study was to test the hypothesis that high fetal echocardiographic study comprehensiveness would be associated with low diagnostic error. Diagnostic errors were defined as discordant fetal and postnatal diagnoses and were further characterized by potential causes, contributors, and clinical significance. Fetal echocardiographic examinations performed at Lucile Packard Children's Hospital in which fetuses with critical congenital heart disease were anticipated to require postnatal surgical or catheter intervention in the first year of life were identified using the fetal cardiology program database. For this cohort, initial fetal echocardiographic images were reviewed and given a fetal echocardiography comprehensiveness score (FECS). Fetal diagnoses obtained from initial fetal echocardiographic images and reports were compared with postnatal diagnoses confirmed by transthoracic echocardiography and other imaging studies and/or surgery to determine diagnostic error. The relationship between FECS and diagnostic error was evaluated using multivariable logistic regression. Of the 304 initial fetal echocardiographic studies, diagnostic error (discrepant diagnosis, false negative, or false positive) occurred in 92 cases (30.3%). FECS was not associated with diagnostic error, but low FECS (≤80% complete) was associated with false negatives and procedural/conditional (P<.001) and technical (P=.005) contributors compared with high FECS (>80% complete). Cognitive factors made up the largest proportion of contributors to error. The comprehensiveness of fetal echocardiographic studies was not related to diagnostic error. The most common contributors to error were cognitive factors. Echocardiography laboratories can work to mitigate preventable cognitive error through quality improvement initiatives.