Gross cycling efficiency is not altered with and without toe-clips

Abstract

The aim of this study was to examine the claim that reductions of 8 – 18% in submaximal oxygen consumption ([Vdot]O2) could be due to changing components on a Monark ergometer, from standard pedals without toe-clips or straps (flat pedals) to racing pedals of that era, which included toe-clips and straps (toe-clip pedals). This previously untested assertion was evaluated using 11 males (mean age 22.3 years, s = 1.2; height 1.82 m, s = 0.07; body mass 82.6 kg, s = 8.8) who completed four trials in a randomized, counterbalanced order at 60 rev · min−1 on a Monark cycle ergometer. Two trials were completed on flat pedals and two trials on toe-clip pedals. The Douglas bag method was used to assess [Vdot]O2 and gross efficiency during successive 5-min workloads of 60, 120, 180, and 240 W. The mean [Vdot]O2 was 2.1% higher for toe-clip pedals than flat pedals and there was a 99% probability that toe-clip pedals would not result in an 8% lower [Vdot]O2. These results indicate that toe-clip pedals do not reduce [Vdot]O2.