GPT vs. Google: A Comparative Study of Self-Code Learning in ODL Students

Abstract

This research investigates the comparative effectiveness of the ChatGPT and the Google search engine in facilitating the self-learning of JavaScript functions among undergraduate open and distance learning students. Employing a quasi-experimental post-test control group design, the study analyzed variables of disorientation, satisfaction, cognitive load, navigation performance, and test scores among 471 learners. Results indicated a marked advantage for ChatGPT users in reducing cognitive load and disorientation, improving navigation performance and increasing test scores. The study also explores the evolving dynamics between conventional keyword-based search engines and AI-driven conversational models, reflecting on their mutual influence in the domain of information retrieval. These findings suggest that AI chatbots like ChatGPT not only enhance the learning experience but also signify a paradigm shift in how information is accessed and processed in educational settings. The research contributes to the understanding of AI applications in education, particularly in self-directed learning scenarios in open and distance learning.