Glycolytic strategy as a tradeoff between energy yield and protein cost

The Embden-Meyerhof (EM) or Entner-Doudoroff (ED) pathways of sugar degradation were analyzed in representative species of the hyperthermophilic archaeal genera Thermococcus, Desulfurococcus, Thermoproteus, and Sulfolobus, and in the hyperthermophilic (eu)bacterial genus Thermotoga. The analyses included (1) determination of 13C-labeling patterns by 1H- and 13C-NMR spectroscopy of fermentation products derived from pyruvate after fermentation of specifically 13C-labeled glucose by cell suspensions, (2) identification of intermediates of sugar degradation after conversion of 14C-labeled glucose by cell extracts, and (3) measurements of enzyme activities in cell extracts. Thermococcus celer and Thermococcus litoralis fermented 13C-glucose to acetate and alanine via a modified EM pathway (100%). This modification involves ADP-dependent hexokinase, 6-phosphofructokinase, and glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate:ferredoxin oxidoreductase (GAP:FdOR). Desulfurococcus amylolyticus fermented 13C-glucose to acetate via a modified EM pathway in which GAP:FdOR replaces GAP-DH/phosphoglycerate kinase. Thermoproteus tenax fermented 13C-glucose to low amounts of acetate and alanine via simultaneous operation of the EM pathway (85%) and the ED pathway (15%). Aerobic Sulfolobus acidocaldarius fermented 13C-labeled glucose to low amounts of acetate and alanine exclusively via the ED pathway. The anaerobic (eu)bacterium Thermotoga maritima fermented 13C-glucose to acetate and lactate via the EM pathway (85%) and the ED pathway (15%). Cell extracts contained glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase and 2-keto-3-deoxy-6-phosphogluconate aldolase, key enzymes of the conventional phosphorylated ED pathway, and, as reported previously, all enzymes of the conventional EM pathway. In conclusion, glucose was degraded by hyperthermophilic archaea to pyruvate either via modified EM pathways with different types of hexose kinases and GAP-oxidizing enzymes, by the nonphosphorylated ED pathway, or by a combination of both pathways. In contrast, glucose catabolism in the hyperthermophilic (eu)bacterium Thermotoga involves the conventional forms of the EM and ED pathways. The data are in accordance with various previous reports.

The R and M phase variants of Rhodobacter sphaeroides and Rhodobacter capsulatus were isolated. The growth rates in the dark and in the light in glucose-containing media were much higher for the Rba. sphaeroides R variant than for the M variant. For the Rba. capsulatus R and M variants, growth rates in the dark and in the light in fructose- or glucose-containing media differed insignificantly. The cells of Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus phase variants growing in media with glucose and fructose exhibited differences in activity of the key enzymes of the Embden–Meyerhof–Parnas (EMP) and Entner–Doudoroff (ED) pathways. The oxidative pentose phosphate pathway (PPP) does not participate in glucose and fructose metabolism in the studied bacteria. Specific activity of the ED pathway enzymes was higher in dark-grown R and M variants of both Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus than in the cells grown under light. Specific activity of the EMP enzymes was higher for the R and M variants of both cultures grown in the light than for those grown in the dark. Activities of the 2-keto-3-deoxy-6-phosphogluconate and fructose bisphosphate aldolases, the key enzymes of the ED and EMP pathways in Rba. sphaeroides M variant grown in the medium with glucose in the light or in the dark, were approximately twice those of the R variant. In the medium with fructose activities of these enzymes in both R and M variants did not change significantly depending on growth conditions. Activities of the enzymes of the EMP and ED pathways in the extracts of the Rba. capsulatus R and M cells grown with glucose or fructose did not change significantly. Cultivation of Rba. sphaeroides and Rba. capsulatus phase variants in the medium with fructose resulted in a considerably increased synthesis of 1-phosphofructokinase. Induction of 1-phosphofructokinase synthesis in Rba. sphaeroides occurred only in the light, while in Rba. capsulatus induction of this enzyme in the medium with fructose was observed both in the dark and in the light. Thus, under aerobic conditions in the dark the phase variants of both bacteria probably assimilated glucose and fructose via the ED pathway, while in the light the EMP pathway was active.

BackgroundIn engineered strains of Escherichia coli, bioconversion efficiency is determined by not only metabolic flux but also the turnover efficiency of relevant pathways. Methyl-d-erythritol 4-phosphate (MEP)-dependent carotenoid biosynthesis in E. coli requires efficient turnover of precursors and balanced flux among precursors, cofactors, and cellular energy. However, the imbalanced supply of glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate (G3P) and pyruvate precursors remains the major metabolic bottleneck. To address this problem, we manipulated various genetic targets related to the Entner–Doudoroff (ED)/pentose phosphate (PP) pathways. Systematic target modification was conducted to improve G3P and pyruvate use and rebalance the precursor and redox fluxes.ResultsCarotenoid production was improved to different degrees by modifying various targets in the Embden–Meyerhof–Parnas (EMP) and ED pathways, which directed metabolic flux from the EMP pathway towards the ED pathway. The improvements in yield were much greater when the MEP pathway was enhanced. The coordinated modification of ED and MEP pathway targets using gene expression enhancement and protein coupling strategies in the pgi deletion background further improved carotenoid synthesis. The fine-tuning of flux at the branch point between the ED and PP pathways was important for carotenoid biosynthesis. Deletion of pfkAB instead of pgi reduced the carotenoid yield. This suggested that anaplerotic flux of G3P and pyruvate might be necessary for carotenoid biosynthesis. Improved carotenoid yields were accompanied by increased biomass and decreased acetate overflow. Therefore, efficient use of G3P and pyruvate precursors resulted in a balance among carotenoid biosynthesis, cell growth, and by-product metabolism.ConclusionsAn efficient and balanced MEP-dependent carotenoid bioconversion strategy involving both the ED and PP pathways was implemented by the coordinated modification of diverse central metabolic pathway targets. In this strategy, enhancement of the ED pathway for efficient G3P and pyruvate turnover was crucial for carotenoid production. The anaplerotic role of the PP pathway was important to supply precursors for the ED pathway. A balanced metabolic flux distribution among precursor supply, NADPH generation, and by-product pathways was established.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12934-015-0301-x) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Metabolic engineering is crucial in the development of production strains for platform chemicals, pharmaceuticals and biomaterials from renewable resources. The central carbon metabolism (CCM) of heterotrophs plays an essential role in the conversion of biomass to the cellular building blocks required for growth. Yet, engineering the CCM ultimately aims toward a maximization of flux toward products of interest. The most abundant dissimilative carbohydrate pathways amongst prokaryotes (and eukaryotes) are the Embden-Meyerhof-Parnas (EMP) and the Entner-Doudoroff (ED) pathways, which build the basics for heterotrophic metabolic chassis strains. Although the EMP is regarded as the textbook example of a carbohydrate pathway owing to its central role in production strains like Escherichia coli, Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Bacillus subtilis, it is either modified, complemented or even replaced by alternative carbohydrate pathways in different organisms. The ED pathway also plays key roles in biotechnological relevant bacteria, like Zymomonas mobilis and Pseudomonas putida, and its importance was recently discovered in photoautotrophs and marine microorganisms. In contrast to the EMP, the ED pathway and its variations are not evolutionary optimized for high ATP production and it differs in key principles such as protein cost, energetics and thermodynamics, which can be exploited in the construction of unique metabolic designs. Single ED pathway enzymes and complete ED pathway modules have been used to rewire carbon metabolisms in production strains and for the construction of cell-free enzymatic pathways. This review focuses on the differences of the ED and EMP pathways including their variations and discusses the use of alternative pathway strategies for in vivo and cell-free metabolic engineering.

Glucose degradation pathways are central for energy and carbon metabolism throughout all domains of life. They provide ATP, NAD(P)H, and biosynthetic precursors for amino acids, nucleotides, and fatty acids. It is general knowledge that cyanobacteria and plants oxidize carbohydrates via glycolysis [the Embden-Meyerhof-Parnas (EMP) pathway] and the oxidative pentose phosphate (OPP) pathway. However, we found that both possess a third, previously overlooked pathway of glucose breakdown: the Entner-Doudoroff (ED) pathway. Its key enzyme, 2-keto-3-deoxygluconate-6-phosphate (KDPG) aldolase, is widespread in cyanobacteria, moss, fern, algae, and plants and is even more common among cyanobacteria than phosphofructokinase (PFK), the key enzyme of the EMP pathway. Active KDPG aldolases from the cyanobacterium Synechocystis and the plant barley (Hordeum vulgare) were biochemically characterized in vitro. KDPG, a metabolite unique to the ED pathway, was detected in both in vivo, indicating an active ED pathway. Phylogenetic analyses revealed that photosynthetic eukaryotes acquired KDPG aldolase from the cyanobacterial ancestors of plastids via endosymbiotic gene transfer. Several Synechocystis mutants in which key enzymes of all three glucose degradation pathways were knocked out indicate that the ED pathway is physiologically significant, especially under mixotrophic conditions (light and glucose) and under autotrophic conditions in a day/night cycle, which is probably the most common condition encountered in nature. The ED pathway has lower protein costs and ATP yields than the EMP pathway, in line with the observation that oxygenic photosynthesizers are nutrient-limited, rather than ATP-limited. Furthermore, the ED pathway does not generate futile cycles in organisms that fix CO2 via the Calvin-Benson cycle.

Highly efficient methane assimilation through Embden-Meyerhof-Parnas pathway in Methylomicrobium alcaliphilum 20Z

The Entner-Doudoroff (ED) pathway was first discovered in 1952 in Pseudomonas saccharophila (21) and several years later was shown to be present in Escherichia coli (23). Although generally considered to be restricted to gram-negative bacteria, the ED pathway is present in all three phylogenetic domains, including the most deeply rooted Archaea (18). The ubiquity of the ED pathway suggests that it is of far greater importance in nature than was previously recognized. In fact, a recent essay on the evolution of glycolytic pathways suggested that the ED pathway predates the Embden-Meyerhof-Parnas pathway (60). E. coli is generally recognized as a member of the normal gastrointestinal microbiota and is extremely versatile, with the ability to grow on many of the nutrients that can be found there (45). But what exactly are the nutrients preferred by E. coli to support its growth in the intestine? And what about growth of E. coli outside of the intestine? Certainly E. coli spends periods of time in aquatic, aerobic habitats when it is in between host intestinal tracts. Mounting evidence suggests that sugar acid metabolism via the ED pathway is important for growth of E. coli in both intestinal and aquatic habitats. The role of the ED pathway, especially with regard to colonization of the mammalian large intestine, will be discussed below. The biochemistry and physiology of sugar acid metabolism in E. coli are very well understood, and several newly discovered genes encoding sugar acid transporters, associated regulatory proteins, and a novel pathway for sugar acid catabolism have been identified as a result of the E. coli genome project (12). Homology searches reveal that the genes of the ED pathway are present on several other genomes (Table 1), and it is becoming clear that there will be additional, perhaps even novel, sugar acid catabolic pathways revealed by analysis of these genomes. OVERVIEW OF THE ED PATHWAY The ED pathway can be properly considered as one of three pathways found in nature, in addition to the Embden-Meyerhof-Parnas and pentose phosphate pathways, that feed into the “bottom half” of glycolysis, which is central to all of intermediary metabolism (18, 28). The overall schemes of the ED and Embden-Meyerhof-Parnas pathways are quite similar: 6-carbon sugars are primed by phosphorylation and subsequently cleaved by aldolase enzymes into two 3-carbon intermediates (Fig. 1). The primary distinction between the two pathways lies in the nature of the 6-carbon metabolites that serve as substrates for aldol cleavage: for the ED pathway this intermediate is 2-keto-3-deoxy-6-phosphogluconate (KDPG). The first of the two key enzymes is unique to the ED pathway, 6-phosphogluconate dehydratase (Edd), which catalyzes a dehydration of 6-phosphogluconate to form KDPG. The second enzyme of the ED pathway, KDPG aldolase (Eda), catalyzes an aldol cleavage of KDPG to form pyruvate and glyceraldehyde3-phosphate. The triose phosphate intermediate is further metabolized by the glycolytic pathway and provides energy via substrate-level phosphorylation.

The ability of biological systems to adapt to genetic and environmental perturbations is a fundamental but poorly understood process at the molecular level. By quantifying metabolic fluxes and global mRNA abundance, we investigated the genetic and metabolic mechanisms that underlie adaptive evolution of four metabolic gene deletion mutants of Escherichia coli (delta pgi, delta ppc, delta pta, and delta tpi) in parallel evolution experiments of each mutant. The initial response to the gene deletions was flux rerouting through local bypass reactions or normally latent pathways. The principal effect of evolution was improved capacity of already active pathways, whereas new flux distributions were not observed. Combinatorial changes in capacity and pathway activation, however, led to different intracellular flux states that enabled evolution in three of the four parallel cases tested. The molecular bases of the evolved phenotypes were then elucidated by global mRNA transcript analyses. Activation of latent pathways and flux changes in the tricarboxylic acid cycle were found to correlate well with molecular changes at the transcriptional level. Flux alterations in other central metabolic pathways, in contrast, were apparently not connected to changes in the transcriptional network. These results give new insight into the dynamics of the evolutionary process by demonstrating the flexibility of the metabolic network of E. coli to compensate for genetic perturbations and the utility of combining multiple high throughput data sets to differentiate between causal and noncausal mechanistic changes.

Methylotuvimicrobium buryatense 5GB1C, a fast-growing gammaproteobacterial methanotroph, is equipped with two glycolytic pathways, the Entner-Doudoroff (ED) pathway and the Embden-Meyerhof-Parnas (EMP) pathway. Metabolic flux analysis and 13C-labeling experiments have shown the EMP pathway is the principal glycolytic route in M. buryatense 5GB1C, while the ED pathway appears to be metabolically and energetically insignificant. However, it has not been possible to obtain a null mutant in the edd-eda genes encoding the two unique enzymatic reactions in the ED pathway, suggesting the ED pathway may be essential for M. buryatense 5GB1C growth. In this study, the inducible P BAD promoter was used to manipulate gene expression of edd-eda, and in addition, the expression of these two genes was separated from that of a downstream gltA gene. The resulting strain shows arabinose-dependent growth that correlates with ED pathway activity, with normal growth achieved in the presence of ∼0.1 g/liter arabinose. Flux balance analysis shows that M. buryatense 5GB1C with a strong ED pathway has a reduced energy budget, thereby limiting the mutant growth at a high concentration of arabinose. Collectively, our study demonstrates that the ED pathway is essential for M. buryatense 5GB1C. However, no known mechanism can directly explain the essentiality of the ED pathway, and thus, it may have a yet unknown regulatory role required for sustaining a healthy and functional metabolism in this bacterium.IMPORTANCE The gammaproteobacterial methanotrophs possess a unique central metabolic architecture where methane and other reduced C1 carbon sources are assimilated through the ribulose monophosphate cycle. Although efforts have been made to better understand methanotrophic metabolism in these bacteria via experimental and computational approaches, many questions remain unanswered. One of these is the essentiality of the ED pathway for M. buryatense 5GB1C, as current results appear contradictory. By creating a construct with edd-eda and gltA genes controlled by P BAD and P J23101 , respectively, we demonstrated the essentiality of the ED pathway for this obligate methanotroph. It is also demonstrated that these genetic tools are applicable to M. buryatense 5GB1C and that expression of the target genes can be tightly controlled across an extensive range. Our study adds to the expanding knowledge of methanotrophic metabolism and practical approaches to genetic manipulation for obligate methanotrophs.

BackgroundThe presence of the branched Entner-Doudoroff (ED) pathway in two hyperthermophilic Crenarchaea, the anaerobe Thermoproteus tenax and the aerobe Sulfolobus solfataricus, was suggested. However, so far no enzymatic information of the non-phosphorylative ED branch and especially its key enzyme – glycerate kinase – was available. In the T. tenax genome, a gene homolog with similarity to putative hydroxypyruvate reductase/glycerate dehydrogenase and glycerate kinase was identified.ResultsThe encoding gene was expressed in E. coli in a recombinant form, the gene product purified and the glycerate kinase activity was confirmed by enzymatic studies. The enzyme was active as a monomer and catalyzed the ATP-dependent phosphorylation of D-glycerate forming exclusively 2-phosphoglycerate. The enzyme was specific for glycerate and highest activity was observed with ATP as phosphoryl donor and Mg2+ as divalent cation. ATP could be partially replaced by GTP, CTP, TTP and UTP. The enzyme showed high affinity for D-glycerate (Km 0.02 ± 0.01 mM, Vmax of 5.05 ± 0.52 U/mg protein) as well as ATP (Km of 0.03 ± 0.01 mM, Vmax of 4.41 ± 0.04 U/mg protein), although at higher glycerate concentrations, substrate inhibition was observed. Furthermore, the enzyme was inhibited by its product ADP via competitive inhibition. Data bank searches revealed that archaeal glycerate kinases are members of the MOFRL (multi-organism fragment with rich leucine) family, and homologs are found in all three domains of life.ConclusionA re-evaluation of available genome sequence information as well as biochemical and phylogenetic studies revealed the presence of the branched ED pathway as common route for sugar degradation in Archaea that utilize the ED pathway. Detailed analyses including phylogenetic studies demonstrate the presence of three distinct glycerate kinase classes in extant organisms that share no common origin. The affiliation of characterized glycerate kinases with the different enzyme classes as well as their physiological/cellular function reveals no association with particular pathways but a separate phylogenetic distribution. This work highlights the diversity and complexity of the central carbohydrate metabolism. The data also support a key function of the conversion of glycerate to 2- or 3-phosphoglycerate via glycerate kinase in funneling various substrates into the common EMP pathway for catabolic and anabolic purposes.

Optogenetics is an attractive synthetic biology tool for controlling the metabolic flux distribution. Here, we demonstrated optogenetic flux ratio control of glycolytic pathways consisting of the Embden-Meyerhof-Parnas (EMP), pentose phosphate (PP), and Entner-Doudoroff (ED) pathways by illuminating multicolor lights using blue light-responsive EL222 and green/red light-responsive CcaSR in Escherichia coli. EL222 forms a dimer and binds to a particular DNA sequence under blue light; therefore, target gene expression can be reduced or induced by inserting a recognition sequence into its promoter regions. First, a flux ratio between the PP and ED pathways was controlled by blue light using EL222. After blocking the EMP pathway, the EL222-recognition sequence was inserted between the -35 and -10 regions of gnd to repress the PP flux and was also inserted upstream of the -35 region of edd to induce ED flux. After adjusting light intensity, the PP:ED flux ratios were 60:39% and 29:70% under dark and blue light conditions, respectively. Finally, a CcaSR-based pgi expression system was implemented to control the flux ratio between the EMP and PP + ED pathways by illuminating green/red light. The EMP:PP:ED flux ratios were 80:9:11%, 14:35:51%, and 33:5:62% under green, red, and red and blue light, respectively.

Glycolysis is a universal metabolic process that breaks down glucose to produce adenosine triphosphate (ATP) and biomass precursors. The Entner-Doudoroff (ED) pathway is a glycolytic pathway that parallels textbook glycolysis but yields half as much ATP. Accordingly, in organisms that possess both glycolytic pathways (for example, Escherichia coli), its raison d'être remains a mystery. In this study, we found that the ED pathway provides a selective advantage during growth acceleration. Upon carbon and nitrogen upshifts, E. coli accelerates growth faster with than without the ED pathway. Concurrent isotope tracing reveals that the ED pathway flux increases faster than that of textbook glycolysis. We attribute the fast response time of the ED pathway to its strong thermodynamic driving force and streamlining of glucose import. Intermittent nutrient supply manifests the evolutionary advantage of the parallel glycolysis; thus, the dynamic nature of an ostensibly redundant pathway's role in promoting rapid adaptation constitutes a metabolic design principle.

Glucose catabolism of Pseudomonas putida is carried out exclusively through the Entner-Doudoroff (ED) pathway due to the absence of 6-phosphofructokinase. In order to activate the Embden-Meyerhof-Parnas (EMP) route we transferred the pfkA gene from Escherichia coli to a P. putida wild-type strain as well as to an eda mutant, i.e. lacking 2-keto-3-deoxy-6-phosphogluconate aldolase. PfkA(E. coli) failed to redirect the carbon flow from the ED route towards the EMP pathway, suggesting that ED was essential for sugar catabolism. The presence of PfkA(E. coli) was detrimental for growth, which could be traced to the reduction of ATP and NAD(P)H pools along with alteration of the NAD(P)H/NADP(+) ratio. Pseudomonas putida cells carrying PfkA(E. coli) became highly sensitive to diamide and hydrogen peroxide, the response to which is very demanding of NADPH. The inhibitory effect of PfkA(E. coli) could in part be relieved by methionine, the synthesis of which relies much on NADPH. These results expose the role of the ED pathway for generating the redox currency (NADPH) that is required for counteracting oxidative stress. It is thus likely that environmental bacteria that favour the ED pathway over the EMP pathway do so in order to gear their aerobic metabolism to endure oxidative-related insults.

To improve the amino acid production by metabolic engineering, eliminating the pathway bottleneck is known to be very effective. The metabolic response of Methylophilus methylotrophus upon the addition of glucose and of pyruvate was investigated in batch cultivation. We found that the supply of pyruvate is a bottleneck in L-lysine production in M. methylotrophus from methanol as carbon source. M. methylotrophus has a ribulose monophosphate (RuMP) pathway for methanol assimilation, and consequently synthesized fructose-6-phosphate is metabolized to pyruvate via the Entner-Doudoroff (ED) pathway, and the ED pathway is thought to be the main pathway for pyruvate supply. An L-lysine producer of M. methylotrophus with an enhanced ED pathway was constructed by the introduction of the E. coli edd-eda operon encoding the enzyme involving the ED pathway. In this strain, the overall enzymatic activity of ED pathway, which is estimated by measuring the activities of 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase plus 2-keto-3-deoxy-6-phosphogluconate aldolase, was about 20 times higher than in the parent. This strain produced 1.2 times more L-lysine than the parent producer. Perhaps, then, the supply of pyruvate was a bottleneck in L-lysine production in the L-lysine producer of M. methylotrophus.

The actinomycete Nonomuraea sp. ATCC 39727, producer of the glycopeptide A40926 that is used as precursor for the novel antibiotic dalbavancin, has an unusual carbon metabolism. Glucose is primarily metabolized via the Entner-Doudoroff (ED) pathway, although the energetically more favorable Embden-Meyerhof-Parnas (EMP) pathway is present in this organism. Moreover, Nonomuraea utilizes a PPi-dependent phosphofructokinase, an enzyme that has been connected with anaerobic metabolism in eukaryotes and higher plants, but recently has been recognized in several actinomycetes. In order to study its primary carbon metabolism in further detail, Nonomuraea was cultivated with [1-13C] glucose as the only carbon source and the 13C-labeling patterns of proteinogenic amino acids were determined by GC-MS analysis. Through this method, the fluxes in the central carbon metabolism during balanced growth were estimated. Moreover, a shift in the label incorporation pattern was observed in connection with phosphate limitation and increased antibiotic productivity in Nonomuraea. The shift indicated an increased flux through the EMP pathway at the expense of the flux through the ED pathway, a suggestion that was supported by alterations in intracellular metabolite levels during phosphate limitation. In contrast, expression levels of genes encoding enzymes in the ED and EMP pathways were not affected by phosphate limitation.