Global Positioning System–Determined and Stopwatch-Determined Running Speeds of Horses Differ

Abstract

Global positioning systems (GPS) have become very popular tools to determine the running speed of horses. However, information on the accuracy of these measurements is scarce. The objective of this study was to examine the accuracy of speed determinations using GPS. For this purpose, the running speeds determined using the GPS of the Polar M400 Equine heart rate meter (G-speed) and a stopwatch (W-speed; manual division of the measured time over the distance run) were compared. The hypothesis was that the speeds determined by both methods would be the same. Eleven horses ran a standardized exercise test (SET) with 130 m laps, and 8 horses ran a SET with 250 m laps in two different sandy riding arenas (one was indoor). The length of the laps was determined with a distance measuring wheel and marked with red traffic cones for the riders to maintain an accurate course. The SETs consisted of five intervals at increasing speeds each. The duration of the intervals was between 3 and 6 minutes. Horses ran a defined number of laps in each interval to reach the prescribed durations. Data were analyzed using a paired Student’s t-test; P < .05 denoted significance. W-speeds differed from G-speeds for all intervals in both riding arenas (P between .01 and .001). G-speed was lower for each interval. With increasing speed, the difference between the two methods augmented. The hypothesis was rejected, therefore questioning the accuracy of the Polar M400 in determining speed under the conditions of this study.