Geochemical characteristics of aluminum depleted and undepleted komatiites and HREE-enriched low-Ti tholeiites, western Abitibi greenstone belt: A heterogeneous mantle plume-convergent margin environment

Abstract

A compositionally diverse suite of komatiites, komatiitic basalts, and basalts coexist in the Tisdale volcanic assemblage of the late-Archean (∼2.7 Ga) Abitibi greenstone belt. The komatiites are characterized by a spectrum of REE patterns, from low total REE contents (9 ppm) and pronounced convex-up patterns to greater total REE (18 ppm) and approximately flat-distributions. Thorium and niobium are codepleted with LREE. Komatiites with the most convex-up patterns have low Al 2O 3 (4.7 wt%) contents and Al 2O 3/TiO 2(12) ratios; they are interpreted to be the Al-depleted variety of komatiite derived from a depleted mantle source. Those komatiites and komatiitic basalts with flatter REE patterns are characterized by greater Al 2O 3 (7.0 wt%) and near chondritic Al 2O 3/TiO 2 (20) ratios; they are interpreted to be Al-undepleted komatiites generated from trace element undepleted mantle. For the komatiites and komatiitic basalts collectively, Gd Yb n ratios are negatively correlated with La Sm n , but positively with MgO and Ni. The spectrum of patterns is interpreted as mixing between Al, HREE, Y-depleted, and Sc-depleted komatiites and Al-undepleted komatiites in a heterogeneous mantle plume. Auminum-depleted komatiites are characterized by negative Zr and Hf anomalies, consistent with majorite garnet-liquid D's for HFSE and REEs, signifying melt segregation at depths of >400 km. Tisdale Al-undepleted komatiites and komatiitic basalts have small negative to zero Zr(Hf)/MREE fractionation, signifying melt segregation in or above the garnet stability field. Collectively, the komatiites have correlations of Zr Zr ∗ and Hf/Hf ∗ with Gd Yb n , and hence the Zr(Hf)/MREE fractionations are unlikely to have stemmed from alteration or crustal contamination. Two types of basalts are present. Type I basalts are Mg-tholeiites with near flat REE and primitive mantle normalized patterns, compositionally similar to abundant Mg-tholeiites associated with both Al-undepleted and Al-depleted komatiites in the Abitibi belt. They have absolute concentrations and ratios of most moderately and highly compatible elements comparable to N- MORB (Zr ∼79 vs. 74, Y ∼30 vs. 28, and Zr Y = 2.4–2.9 vs. 2.6 ), but are relatively less depleted in highly incompatible elements and lack positive Nb or P anomalies. Type II basalts are relatively aluminous (Al 2O 3 ∼ 16 wt%), with high Al 2O 3/TiO 2 (24–28) ratios. They are characterized by low Th, Nb, and LREE contents at eight to ten times chondrite, with slightly convex-up LREE patterns ( La Sm n = 0.86–0.99 ), but strongly fractionated and enriched HREEs, Y, and Sc, where Gd Yb n = 0.50–0.55 and consistently positive Zr(Hf)/MREEs anomalies. These basalts are tentatively interpreted as low-Ti tholeiites formed in a convergent margin setting with second stage melting, induced by fluids and melts enriched in incompatible elements and Zr(Hf) relative to MREEs, of a mantle source depleted during first stage melting. They are analogous to the Phanerozoic low-Ti tholeiite—boninite association. Accordingly the Tisdale volcanic sequence records a plume-convergent margin interaction. New analyses of Al-undepleted komatiites from the classical locality at Pyke Hill in Munro Township confirm the presence of small positive anomalies of P, Zr, and Hf, with Zr Hf ratios generally < 36. These signatures are similar in spinifex and cumulate zones signifying that they are unlikely to have resulted from alteration. The data were generated by INAA and ICP-MS using both HFHNO 3 dissolution and Na 2O 2 sinter. The lack of LREE enrichment with negative Nb, Ta, P, and Ti anomalies in any of the Tisdale or Munro komatiites confirms an intraoceanic setting for the volcanic stage of the Western Abitibi greenstone belt.