Forkhead box P3‐positive regulatory T‐cells and interleukin 17‐positive T‐helper 17 cells in chronic inflammatory periodontal disease

Abstract

The role of two recently identified and closely related T-helper cell subsets - regulatory T-cells [Tregs; forkhead box P3-positive (FOXP3(+) )] and Th17 cells [interleukin-17-positive (IL-17(+) )] - in periodontal disease is yet to be determined. Tregs are essential in maintaining peripheral tolerance and regulating the immune response. Th17 cells play a critical role in several autoimmune diseases, inflammation and host defence. The aim of this study was to determine the presence of FOXP3(+) Tregs and IL-17(+) cells, and their possible spatial interaction, in diseased periodontal tissues. Twenty-nine archival tissues with nonspecific gingival inflammation were grouped based on the intensity (minimally or intensely inflamed) and nature (T-cell predominant or B- and plasma-cell predominant) of the inflammatory infiltrate. Using double-labelling immunohistochemistry, the concomitant presence of FOXP3(+) and IL-17(+) cells was determined and their spatial relationship was established. In addition, the proportions of FOXP3(+) and IL-17(+) cells were compared between the groups. Of the 29 gingival specimens investigated, 17 were intensely inflamed (≥1000 inflammatory cells per 0.12mm(2) ) and 12 were minimally inflamed (≤600 cells per 0.12mm(2) ). Based on the percentage of CD19(+) B-cells and plasma cells collectively and CD3(+) T-cells, gingival tissues were also grouped into B- and plasma-cell-predominant gingival tissues (n=21; 50.7% total B- and plasma cells vs. 19.1% T cells; p<0.001) and T-cell-predominant gingival tissues (n=8; 61.0% T-cells vs. 15.2% B- and plasma cells; p=0.007). More FOXP3(+) cells than IL-17(+) cells were observed in all archival gingival tissues examined. A trend towards an increased number of FOXP3(+) cells was observed for intensely inflamed gingival tissues (6.7%) and for B- and plasma-cell-predominant tissues (6.4%) compared with minimally inflamed gingival tissues (4.6%) and T-cell-predominant gingival tissues (4.5%). However, no statistically significant difference in the mean percentage of FOXP3(+) cells between the groups was observed. Interestingly, FOXP3(+) cells were significantly correlated with the B- and plasma-cell/T-cell ratio in B- and plasma-cell-predominant tissues (r=0.713, p<0.001). Overall, there were very few IL-17(+) cells (<1%). All IL-17(+) cells identified in this study had an ovoid/plasmacytoid morphology and were larger in size compared with adjacent inflammatory cells. IL-17(+) and FOXP3(+) cells were not adjacent to each other in any of the areas examined, suggesting that FOXP3(+) Tregs do not directly interact with IL-17(+) cells in diseased gingival tissues. IL-17(+) /FOXP3(+) cells were not detected in the tissues examined. These results show that FOXP3(+) cells are more prominent than IL-17(+) cells in periodontal disease processes, which may suggest a predominant role for FOXP3(+) cells in periodontal disease. Further studies are required to characterize these cells more precisely and to understand, in more detail, their roles in the pathophysiology of periodontal disease.