Fixing Hearts and Protecting Minds

Abstract

Listen

Translate article

Ischemic heart disease is a significant cause of mortality and morbidity in Western populations. Consistent with this, coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery remains one of the most frequently performed major surgeries. Improved survival rates mean that our research focus now extends beyond surgical technique to include quality of postoperative outcome. Postoperative cognitive dysfunction (POCD) has emerged as one of the most challenging and hotly debated issues, with increasing impetus to answer the unresolved question: does fixing the heart come at a cost to the brain? CABG surgery is associated with neurological events including stroke in 1.6%1 and delirium in 5.8%2 of patients. Beyond these severe and marked alterations to neurological function, there has been a widely held belief that CABG surgery is associated with POCD, which may presage a decline toward dementia. Research has been influenced by the 1995 Consensus Statement3 into the study of POCD in patients undergoing CABG surgery. Although the methods of investigation set forth by the Consensus Statement achieved widespread acknowledgment, its specific recommendations have not always been followed.4 Despite significant methodological issues, it seems that the balance of interpretation has historically been in favor of CABG surgery as a cause of significant POCD. More recently, however, a review of a series of publications from a well-controlled longitudinal cohort study conducted at Johns Hopkins5 and a meta-analysis6 suggested that cognition is in fact stable or may even show some improvement after CABG surgery in the majority of patients, at least within the first year (Figures 1 and 2). There is little doubt that POCD affects some patients in the short term, but the pathophysiological mechanisms underlying this and the influence on longer-term cognitive function remain uncertain. For research to progress, we require a paradigmatic shift in our focus from …