Finding critical points using improved scaling Ansätze

Abstract

Analyzing in detail the first corrections to the scaling hypothesis, we develop accelerated methods for the determination of critical points from finite size data. The output of these procedures is sequences of pseudo-critical points which rapidly converge towards the true critical points. The convergence is faster than that obtained with the fastest method available to date, which consists of estimating the location of the gap's closure (the so called phenomenological renormalization group). Having fast converging sequences at our disposal allows us to draw conclusions on the basis of shorter system sizes. This can be extremely important in particularly hard cases such as two-dimensional quantum systems with frustrations, or in Monte Carlo simulations when the sign problem occurs. After reviewing the most efficient techniques available to date, we test the effectiveness of the proposed methods both analytically on the basis of the one-dimensional XY model and numerically at phase transitions occurring in non-integrable spin models. In particular, we show how a new Homogeneity Condition Method is able to produce fast converging sequences in correspondence to the Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless (BKT) transition simply by making use of ground-state quantities on relatively small systems. Remarkably, our method tested on the frustrated spin-1/2 Heisenberg model gives a BKT critical point which is incompatible with the ones present in the past literature based on different methods. This discrepancy raises the fundamental question of determining the correct renormalization group approach and scaling assumptions that yield to the sequences converging to the true critical point. Finally, we formulate a general prescription that allows us to analyze and efficiently locate critical points in a variety of cases, without knowing in advance the universality class of the tested transition. Even if our methods are tested here in one dimension, we expect them to be valid in any spatial dimensionality and both for quantum and classical statistical systems.