Filter-feeding fish (Hypophthalmichthys molitrix) mediated phosphorus recycling versus grazing pressure as drivers of the trophic cascade in large enclosures subsidized by allochthonous detritus

Abstract

Stocking of filter-feeding fish is a common tool used in (sub)tropical Chinese reservoirs to control phytoplankton. However, field investigations have showed that such stocking would enhance instead of controlling phytoplankton in these reservoirs. Reservoirs generally receive a considerable amount of detritus from their catchments which may constitute an important carbon source to filter-feeding fish. Whether direct consumption of detritus increases the availability of dissolved inorganic phosphorus (P) to phytoplankton and thereby provides resilience against the control of phytoplankton biomass is debated. We conducted an enclosure experiment in a (sub)tropical Chinese reservoir (Liuxihe Reservoir) to assess how a gradient of filter-feeding fish (Silver Carp Hypophthalmichthys molitrix) biomass affected P dynamics and fish grazing and predation when subsidized by allochthonous detritus. Fish had strong effects on the dynamics and fluxes of P. TP concentration in the water column increased over time in all enclosures, but the presence of fish slowed its increase. Thus, TP decreased with increasing fish biomass. Fish were a net sink of P to the water column, because they gained mass during the experiment. Moreover, P sequestered by fish could largely account for the lower TP concentrations observed in enclosures with fish compared to fishless enclosures. Fish presence at high biomass strongly reduced the abundance of large zooplankton species and P excretion by zooplankton. However, the negative effect of fish predation on zooplankton was negligible when fish was present at low biomass. Increasing fish biomass increased the relative role of fish in P cycling but decreased the overall P excretion by fish and zooplankton. Compared to enclosures with high fish biomass, both zooplankton grazing effect on phytoplankton (zooplankton: phytoplankton biomass ratio as a proxy) and the overall P excretion were much higher, whereas fish grazing effect on phytoplankton (fish: phytoplankton biomass ratio as a proxy), chlorophyll a and the yield of chlorophyll a per TP were much lower in enclosures with low fish biomass. This suggested that phytoplankton limitation might shift from one of zooplankton control to one of limitation by P availability with increasing fish biomass. Relative to fish mediated P recycling and fish grazing, zooplankton grazing appeared to be more important as a driver of trophic cascades in systems subsidized by allochthonous detritus. Silver Carp stocked at high biomass would strongly reduce zooplankton grazing pressure and increase the yield of phytoplankton per TP.