False-Negative Low Tube Voltage Coronary CT Angiography: High Intravascular Attenuation at Coronary CT Angiography Can Mask Calcified Plaques.

Abstract

To determine the impact of low tube voltage coronary CT angiography on detection of subclinical atherosclerosis. Retrospective sampling of an emergency department coronary CT angiography registry was performed. All patients in the registry underwent a noncontrast coronary artery calcium (CAC) scoring scan at 120 kV before coronary CT angiography. The study sample (n = 264) constituted patients with subclinical atherosclerosis (Coronary Artery Disease Reporting and Data System™ [CAD-RADS] 1 or 2) randomly mixed one-to-one with patients without atherosclerosis (CAD-RADS 0). The patients with coronary CT angiography performed at 70-90 kV were considered the low tube voltage group (n = 159) and patients with coronary CT angiography performed at 100-120 kV were considered the standard tube voltage group (n = 105). The number of coronary plaques and overall CAD-RADS classification (per patient) were evaluated twice: initially, by reading coronary CT angiography alone, and then, by coronary CT angiography in combination with a CAC scan. Considering the combined reading (CT angiography plus CAC scan) as the reference standard, the performance of coronary CT angiography alone was assessed for plaque detection and appropriate CAD-RADS (per patient) classification. The comparisons were made between the low tube voltage and standard tube voltage groups by using a Fisher exact test and χ2 test for proportions and a Mann-Whitney test and Kruskal-Wallis test for means. In total, 455 plaques were identified in 118 patients (70 of 159 patients in the low tube voltage group; 48 of 105 in the standard tube voltage group). When reading coronary CT angiographic images alone, 97 of 455 (21%) plaques were missed that led to an incorrect CAD-RADS classification in 16 of 264 (6%) studies (interpreted as CAD-RADS 0 instead of CAD-RADS 1 or 2). Missed plaques were significantly more frequent in the low tube voltage group versus the standard tube voltage group (41% [85 of 206] vs 5% [12 of 249], respectively; P < .001). Incorrect CAD-RADS classification was also seen more commonly in the low tube voltage group (8.8% [14 of 159] vs 2% [two of 105]; P = .01), typically at low plaque burden (median CAC score, 1; range, 1-4). Calcified plaques that appeared isodense to luminal contrast material attenuation were seen more frequently in the low tube voltage group compared with the standard tube voltage group (20% [32 of 159] vs 7.6% [eight of 105], respectively; P = .005). Coronary artery plaques may be missed at low tube voltage coronary CT angiographic examination performed without a concomitant CAC scan.© RSNA, 2019Supplemental material is available for this article.See also the commentary by Truong in this issue.