Failure of suture material at suture anchor eyelets

Abstract

Purpose: In the repair of soft tissue to bone using suture anchors, failure of the suture material can occur at the anchor eyelet. This study examines the load strength at which suture material fails with different metallic suture anchor eyelets. Type of study: Biomechanical study. Methods: Suture material (Ethibond No. 2, Ethicon, Norderstedt, Germany) was pulled out from 22 metallic suture anchor models at 60 mm/min, and tensile load at failure and failure mode were recorded. Tests were performed either by simultaneous pulling on 2 suture limbs in 3 different directions (straight, at 45°, and at 45° rotated by 90° to the suture anchor axis) or by pulling on 1 suture limb while measuring the resulting force on the second limb. All tests were performed until suture failure. Pulling was performed in single tests on an Instron materials testing machine (High Wycombe, UK), with the anchors held by a vise. Results: In all cases, the suture failed at the anchor eyelet. Failure load at straight loading ranged from 116 ± 5 N to 226 ± 5 N and from 69 ± 5 N to 193 ± 7 N when loaded at an angle of 45°. The best results were found with the Statak 5.2-mm (Zimmer, Warsaw, IN): 177 N; Corkscrew 6.5-mm anchor (Arthrex, Naples, FL): 174 N; and PeBA 4.0-mm anchor (OBL Orthopaedic Biosystems, Scottsdale, AZ): 169 N. With each eyelet, sutures failed preferentially in 1 direction, depending on the presence of sharp edges. Conclusions: Suture material can be cut at suture anchor eyelets. Failure load depends on sharp edges on the eyelet and occurs at forces up to 73% below the breaking strength of the suture material on a smooth hook. Anchors with suture-protecting channels are particularly sensitive to the orientation in which the sutures are loaded.Arthroscopy: The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery, Vol 18, No 9 (November- December), 2002: pp 1013–1019