Facial nerve sacrifice and tumor recurrence in primary and recurrent benign parotid tumors

Abstract

Three hundred eight patients underwent parotidectomy for a benign parotid tumor between 1948 and 1979. Two hundred seventy-four had operation for primary tumor, and 34, for recurrent tumor. Ninety-eight percent of those with primary tumors had superficial or total parotidectomy, and 2 percent had local excision with a wide margin of normal tissue. In those with recurrent tumor, 91 percent had superficial or total parotidectomy and 9 percent had local excision with a wide margin of normal tissue. There were nine recurrences in the primary group (3.2 percent) and 10 in the recurrent group (29 percent), at an average follow-up of 10 and 13 years, respectively. The time to recurrence in the primary group was between 5 and 20 years, whereas second recurrences in the recurrent group generally took place within 5 years. Seven patients in the primary group (2.5 percent) and 9 in the recurrent group (26 percent) had sacrifice of the facial nerve. Most facial nerve sacrifices in the primary group were minor, involving a branch of the nerve only. Facial nerve sacrifice in the recurrent group, however, usually involved division of the nerve or the nerve trunk. These findings demonstrate that the major morbidity associated with managing benign parotid tumors occurs in dealing with recurrent tumors. Recurrence is uncommon if superficial or total parotidectomy is performed for a primary tumor.