Exploring Hourly Updating Probabilistic Guidance in the 2021 Spring Forecasting Experiment with Objective and Subjective Verification

Abstract

Abstract This study explored how forecasters can best use the two main forms of operational convection-allowing model guidance: the High-Resolution Ensemble Forecast (HREF) system and the hourly High-Resolution Rapid Refresh (HRRR). The former represents a wider range of possible outcomes, but the latter updates much more frequently and incorporates newer observations. HREF and time-lagged High-Resolution Rapid Refresh (HRRR-TL) probabilistic forecasts of reflectivity and updraft helicity, as well as two methods of combining HREF and HRRR into hourly updating blended guidance, were evaluated for the 2021 Spring Forecasting Experiment (SFE) period. In both objective skill and the subjective ratings of SFE participants, the 1200 UTC HREF proved difficult to outperform over this sample of events, even when incorporating HRRR initializations as late as 1800 UTC. It was usually better to use either of the experimental blending techniques than to simply discard the older HREF in favor of newer HRRR solutions. The greater model diversity and dispersion of solutions within the HREF is likely primarily responsible for this result. A possible bias in diurnal convection initiation timing and coverage in the newly upgraded HRRRv4 was also investigated, including on subdomains targeted to weakly forced diurnal initiation, and was found to have little or no systematic effect on HRRRv4’s operational utility.