Examining relationships between entrainment-driven scalar dissimilarity and surface energy balance underclosure in a semiarid valley

Abstract

A surface energy budget underclosure, equivalent to an undersampling of sensible and latent heat fluxes at the surface, is commonly observed in the daytime convective boundary layer over land. The two mechanisms currently held responsible for such underclosure are, on one hand, entrainment-induced reduction of heat fluxes due to low-frequency circulations spanning the depth of the convective boundary layer, and on the other hand, horizontal advection effects induced by surface horizontal heterogeneity. Given the involvement of both heat fluxes in the budget equation, it is expected that the turbulent perturbations of variables involved in these fluxes (potential temperature θ′ and specific humidity q′) contain the signature of both mechanisms. Here, we assess to what extent non-local entrainment effects contribute to the budget underclosure in complex terrain using a quadrant analysis and multiresolution flux decomposition approach.We use data collected in the semi-arid Owens Valley, CA, USA, during the Terrain-Induced Rotor Experiment (T-REX) campaign. The budget components are sampled near the surface of the valley floor and the adjacent slope, with turbulence flux measurements, pyranometers, pyrgeometers, as well as ground heat flux measurements. We found that the budget underclosure was within the range of underclosures reported in past studies, with a systematically poorer closure over the valley slope. Although quadrant analysis revealed a dominance of scalar-similar events, associated with convective boundary layer overturning, a high degree of disagreement was found between the scalar-dissimilar quadrants which represent the counter-gradient motions. Specifically, those turbulent motions associated with entrainment of free tropospheric air to the surface, were found to be of minor importance in degrading scalar similarity. Instead, we postulate that local horizontal advection and hectometre-scale land-use heterogeneity in the vicinity of both the valley floor and slope sites, are the major factors in controlling the relationship between the budget underclosure and scalar similarity.