Evolutionary Diversification of Continuous Traits: Phylogenetic Tests and Application to Seed Size in the California Flora

Abstract

Evolutionary diversification of a phenotypic trait reflects the tempo and mode of trait evolution, as well as the phylogenetic topology and branch lengths. Comparisons of trait variance between sister groups provide a powerful approach to test for differences in rates of diversification, controlling for differences in clade age. We used simulation analyses under constant rate Brownian motion to develop phylogenetically based F-tests of the ratio of trait variances between sister groups. Random phylogenies were used for a generalized evolutionary null model, so that detailed internal phylogenies are not required, and both gradual and speciational models of evolution were considered. In general, phylogenetically structured tests were more conservative than corresponding parametric statistics (i.e., larger variance ratios are required to achieve significance). The only exception was for comparisons under a speciational evolutionary model when the group with higher variance has very low sample size (number of species). The methods were applied to a large data set on seed size for 1976 species of California flowering plants. Seven of 37 sister-group comparisons were significant for the phylogenetically structured tests (compared to 12 of 37 for the parametric F-test). Groups with higher diversification of seed size generally had a greater diversity of fruit types, life form, or life history as well. The F-test for trait variances provides a simple, phylogenetically structured approach to test for differences in rates of phenotypic diversification and could also provide a valuable tool in the study of adaptive radiations.