Evidence for Participation of 4f and 5d Orbitals in Lanthanide Metal–Ligand Bonding and That Y(III) Has Less of This Complex-Stabilizing Ability. A Thermodynamic, Spectroscopic, and DFT Study of Their Complexation by the Nitrogen Donor Ligand TPEN

Abstract

The formation constants (log K1) of lanthanide(III) (Ln) ions [except for Pm(III)] and the Y(III) cation have been measured with the ligand TPEN (N,N,N',N'-tetra-2-picolylethylenediamine). These log K1 values show a typical variation with ionic radius, with a local maximum at Sm(III) and a local minimum at Gd(III), with an overall increase in log K1 from La(III) to Lu(III) as the ionic radius decreases. The log K1 for the Y(III)/TPEN complex is much lower than expected from its ionic radius, while the literature log K1 for Am(III) is much higher. The latter effect is thought to be due to greater covalence in the M-L (metal-ligand) bond than for Ln(III) ions: the low log K1 for Y(III) is interpreted as being due to lower covalence. The f → f transitions in the Nd(III) and Pr(III) complexes were examined for effects that might indicate the participation of f orbitals in M-L bonding. The intensity of the f → f transitions in the Nd(III)/TPEN complex was greatly increased compared to that of the Nd3+ aqua ion, which appeared to be due to additional sharp peaks, possibly parity forbidden transitions where parity rules were broken by covalence in the M-L bond. The Pr(III)/TPEN complex showed that all of the f → f transitions shifted to longer wavelengths by some 5 nm, with modest increases in intensity. The effects seen in the f → f transitions of Nd(III) and Pr(III) with TPEN with its six nitrogen donors were present to a much smaller extent in the EDTA and other complexes with fewer nitrogen donors. The changes in the f → f transitions of the TPEN complexes of Er(III) and Ho(III) were small, suggesting a smaller contribution of f orbitals to M-L bonding in these heavier Ln(III) ions. The intense Laporte allowed f → d transitions in Ce(III) complexes show large shifts to longer wavelengths as complexes of, for example, EDTA with increasing numbers of nitrogen donors, suggesting the participation of both f and d orbitals, or either, in M-L bonding. The nature of M-L bonding in M(III)/TPEN complexes was further investigated via density functional theory calculations.