Evidence for organism-wide asymmetry in five bird species of a fragmented afrotropical forest

Abstract

Empirical evidence for between-trait correlation in fluctuating asymmetry (FA) at the individual level is generally lacking or contradictory. Yet the assumption of organism-wide asymmetry, estimated by the asymmetry of any given trait, is inherent to most studies that use FA as a measure of developmental stability (DS). A commonly assumed reason for this weak between-trait correlation is the low repeatability of individual, single-trait asymmetry. In this paper we describe high repeatability and significant between-trait correlation in population- and individual-level FA in five afrotropical bird species inhabiting a fragmented cloud forest. Absence of anti-symmetry and of between-trait correlation in signed FA levels permits us to translate the observed patterns into the presumed underlying DS, using the concept of hypothetical repeatability. This correction, which has not been applied before in this context, proved adequate as it yielded correlations comparable to those found at the population level.