Evaluation of CMIP5 models and ensemble climate projections using a Bayesian approach: a case study of the Upper Indus Basin, Pakistan

Abstract

The availability of a variety of Global Climate Models (GCMs) has increased the importance of the selection of suitable GCMs for impact assessment studies. In this study, we have used Bayesian Model Averaging (BMA) for GCM(s) selection and ensemble climate projection from the output of thirteen CMIP5 GCMs for the Upper Indus Basin (UIB), Pakistan. The results show that the ranking of the top best models among thirteen GCMs is not uniform regarding maximum, minimum temperature, and precipitation. However, some models showed the best performance for all three variables. The selected GCMs were used to produce ensemble projections via BMA for maximum, minimum temperature and precipitation under RCP4.5 and RCP8.5 scenarios for the duration of 2011–2040. The ensemble projections show a higher correlation with observed data than individual GCM’s output, and the BMA’s prediction well captured the trend of observed data. Furthermore, the 90% prediction intervals of BMA’s output closely captured the extreme values of observed data. The projected results of both RCPs were compared with the climatology of baseline duration (1981–2010) and it was noted that RCP8.5 show more changes in future temperature and precipitation compared to RCP4.5. For maximum temperature, there is more variation in monthly climatology for the duration of 2011–2040 in the first half of the year; however, under the RCP8.5, higher variation was noted during the winter season. A decrease in precipitation is projected during the months of January and August under the RCP4.5 while under RCP8.5, decrease in precipitation was noted during the months of March, May, July, August, September, and October; however, the changes (decrease/increase) are higher than under the RCP4.5.