Entropy/Enthalpy Compensation in Anion Binding: Biotin[6]uril and Biotin-l-sulfoxide[6]uril Reveal Strong Solvent Dependency

Abstract

Binding of anions using macrocyclic structures with a nonpolar interior using the CH···anion interaction as the recognition motif has gained popularity in the past few years, and such receptors often rely on a subtle interplay between enthalpic and entropic factors. For these types of receptors solvation of both the anion and the binding pocket of the macrocyclic host play important roles in the overall energetic picture of the binding event. Systematic chemical modifications of synthetic receptors that are able to bind anions in a variety of solvents is an important tool to gain understanding of the factors that determine the supramolecular chemistry of anions. Here we present the chiral macrocyclic structure biotin-l-sulfoxide[6]uril as a host molecule that binds anions in both water and in organic solvents. Biotin-l-sulfoxide[6]uril is prepared in a highly diastereoselective one-pot synthesis from the macrocycle biotin[6]uril. We compare the binding properties with that of biotin[6]uril, also studied in acetonitrile and in aqueous buffer at neutral pH. The biotin-l-sulfoxide[6]uril generally exhibits stronger recognition of anions in acetonitrile, but weaker binding in water as compared to the biotin[6]uril macrocycle. We have studied the binding events using a combination of NMR spectroscopy, isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC), and computational methods.