Electroconvulsive therapy: time to bring it out of the shadows.

Abstract

ELECTROCONVULSIVE THERAPY (ECT) IS ONE OF THE most controversial treatments in all of medicine. There are a number of reasons for this. The discovery in the 1930s that inducing a series of generalized seizures, initially with chemicals, later with electric current, could cause the recovery of patients with severe and previously untreatable mental disorders produced a wave of enthusiasm that eventually led to a period of indiscriminate use and misuse in the middle decades of the 20th century. This period of abuse created, perhaps deservedly at that time, a bad reputation for an effective treatment modality. That reputation was enhanced by the immediate adverse effects of bitten tongues and even fractured bones and teeth caused by the induction of generalized seizures, and the painful effects of electroshocks administered without anesthesia when they did not successfully induce a seizure with loss of consciousness. The 1975 movie One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest contributed to an erroneous view of ECT as a punitive, painful, and assaultive procedure used by authorities to control inconvenient creativity. That view has been associated with attempts to regulate, or even eliminate, the use of ECT through legislation in a number of jurisdictions, and public fears and distrust about the use of ECT have persisted. The best response to such concerns on the part of physicians is to be aware of the facts about current use of ECT, including its efficacy and possible adverse effects, so they can respond to questions from patients, families, and the public. The indications, possible adverse effects, and current recommendations for treatment procedures have been summarized in a task force report just published by the American Psychiatric Association Committee on Electroconvulsive Therapy. An effective and safe treatment for severe major depression, ECT has had response rates reported in the range of 80% to 90% as a first-line treatment, and in the range of 50% to 60% for patients who have not responded to 1 or more trials of treatment with antidepressant drugs. Electroconvulsive therapy may also be seriously considered as treatment for patients with acute mania, and for patients with schizophrenia who have not responded to adequate trials of antipsychotic medications. As currently practiced, ECT involves the use of informed consent, ultra-brief general anesthesia and muscle relaxants (thus attenuating motor seizure activity) with appropriate airway management, and use of ECT devices to provide adequate ictal responses. Most patients in the United States receive 3 treatments per week, and a course of ECT for major depression generally consists of 6 to 12 treatments, with the course ended or tapered as soon as maximum response has been reached. This usually occurs more quickly than the 4 to 6 weeks required for an adequate trial of an antidepressant drug. There continues to be some controversy about the use of right unilateral or bilateral electrode placement, with right unilateral ECT causing less cognitive adverse effects, but bilateral ECT often viewed as being more effective. A recent randomized controlled trial showed that right unilateral ECT at high dosage was as effective as bilateral ECT in many patients and caused less impairment on several measures of anterograde and retrograde memory. The issue of cognitive adverse effects from ECT is central to its reputation for harm and requires careful consideration to separate facts from myths. Studies of this issue have been reviewed and summarized by the American Psychiatric Association Committee on Electroconvulsive Therapy. Patients experience a variable but usually brief period of disorientation (postictal confusion) immediately after seizure induction. Electroconvulsive therapy also typically results in retrograde amnesia, greatest immediately after the course of treatment and for events that occurred temporally close to the treatment. The extent of the retrograde amnesia usually decreases substantially with time, but many patients have persistent loss of memory for some events that occurred in the interval starting several months before and extending to several weeks after their ECT course. Anterograde amnesia, characterized by rapid forgetting of learned information, also may occur during and immediately following ECT but resolves within a few weeks. Importantly, there is no objective evidence that ECT has any long-term effect on the capacity to learn and retain new information. Assessment of cognitive effects from ECT is complicated by the cognitive impairments associated with the mental disorders being treated. For example, patients with severe depression may have substantial impairments in cognitive function, and patients with schizophrenia or other psychotic