Effects of Vegetation Restoration on Soil Organic Carbon Sequestration and Aggregate Stability in Water-Eroded Environment: A Meta-analysis

Abstract

In order to clarify the differences in the effects of vegetation restoration strategies on soil carbon sequestration and aggregate stability under different water-eroded environments, we collected experimental data from 91 papers and evaluated the response of soil organic carbon (SOC) stock and aggregate stability to vegetation restoration based on Meta-analysis. The results showed the following:① compared with cropland or bare land, forestland/grassland restoration was beneficial to increase SOC stock and improve aggregate stability, but the dominant functions of the two were different. The effect of forestland restoration on carbon sequestration was stronger than that of grassland reforestation, and the effect of grassland restoration on aggregate stability was stronger than that of forestland restoration. ② Multi-factor Meta-analysis showed that the factors that significantly affected SOC were restoration year, soil clay content, vegetation coverage, mean annual precipitation (MAP), mean annual temperature (MAT), and soil depth. The positive effect of vegetation restoration on SOC stock increased with the increase in vegetation coverage rate. Grassland restoration had a more significant effect on SOC stock when soil clay content was 20%-32%, it was more likely to promote the carbon sequestration effect of grassland when MAP>800 mm or MAT<15℃, and there was no significant change in SOC stock under different restoration years. However, the effect of forestland restoration on SOC stock was more significant when soil clay content was>32%. Climate conditions had no limited effect on SOC stock in forestland, and there was a positive effect between SOC stock under forestland restoration and restoration years. ③ Vegetation restoration had stronger significant positive effects on mean weight diameter (MWD) and mean geometric diameter (GMD) when the clay content was 20%-32%, and MWD and GMD increased with the increase in vegetation coverage. ④SOC stock growth could explain 25% and 24% of the variation in the effect value of MWD and GMD, respectively. These results indicated that the formation of SOC was the result of multiple factors, and soil aggregate stability was limited only by vegetation coverage and soil clay content. The increase in SOC stock could promote the improvement of water stability MWD and GMD. These results can clarify the carbon sequestration effect of different vegetation restoration measures in water-eroded environments and provide theoretical reference for the restoration and reconstruction of degraded ecosystems.