Effects of stone topography on abundance of net-building caddisfly larvae and arthropod diversity in an upland stream

Abstract

We investigated whether small pits on the surfaces of stream stones affected abundances of net-spinning, hydropsychid larvae (Trichoptera) and species diversity in the Acheron River, southeastern Australia. On stream stones, nets occurred more often in small (at least 5 mm width) pits than expected by chance. However, proportionately high numbers of pits were not associated with high abundances of either of two species of hydropsychid larvae (both Asmicridea spp). A colonization experiment, using bricks with 0, 4, 12 or 30 small (diam. 5.5 mm) and large (13 mm) pits drilled into the top surfaces, showed that numbers of nets were related to numbers of pits. Small pits were preferred over large ones and the pits, as a group, were occupied almost entirely by late instars of both species. However, only Asmicridea sp. 1 was more abundant on pitted bricks; Asmicridea sp. 2 showed no response. The differences between the species, and between the stone and brick results, can be explained by different proportions of late instars in the samples. Many I instars probably did not make nets. Hence, higher numbers of larvae on pitted surfaces is expected only when late instars are relatively frequent, as was true for Asmicridea sp. 1 on bricks. There were no effects of pits per se or increased numbers of hydropsychid nets on species diversity or the abundances of other common species. These results contrast with those of other studies, which found stone topography or hydropsychid nets to increase species diversity on stones.