Effect of water movement in frozen soil on long-term hydrological simulation of Soil and Water Assessment Tool in cold climate watershed in Hokkaido, Japan

Abstract

ABSTRACT Despite the unique hydrological properties exhibited by frozen soil, its characteristics are often oversimplified in most distributed hydrological models, resulting in major errors in material cycle predictions in cold climate regions. This study aims to modify the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT), a semi-distributed hydrological model that originally assumes no water movement in frozen soil layers, by incorporating the dynamic change of soil permeability based on the degree of soil freezing, and to understand the effect of water movement in frozen soil on watershed hydrology. SWAT with frozen soil permeability (SWAT-FSP) was developed by adding two modules to the original SWAT: a heat conduction equation that considers the phase change of ice and liquid water and a frozen-soil percolation model that considers dynamic decrease in soil permeability due to soil freezing. The original SWAT and SWAT-FSP were set up in the Tokoro River watershed in northern Japan. The river flow and soil water dynamics during the snowmelt period (March–May) simulated using the original SWAT and SWAT-FSP were compared. The modified model significantly alters the soil water dynamics simulation to generate earlier soil water drainage and reduces the soil water content during the snowmelt period in years featuring weak soil freezing. Consequently, the SWAT-FSP estimated an earlier increase in river flow at the beginning of the snowmelt period and a smaller river flow in the middle of the snowmelt period as compared with the original SWAT. The modified model improved the overall performance in river flow simulation for the snowmelt period (March–May) of 2012–2019. The Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency obtained during the calibration period by the original SWAT was 0.602, and during the validation period it was 0.367. For the SWAT-FSP, it was 0.659 during calibration, and 0.639 during validation. Meanwhile, the SWAT-FSP showed unsatisfactory performance in 2014 and 2015, with underestimated snow water equivalent, indicating that improvements in the snowmelt/accumulation module may further enhance its accuracy. Our results showed that the dynamic change of soil permeability governed by the degree of soil freezing is an important factor affecting the water cycle of cold climate watersheds with seasonally frozen soil.