Effect of industrialization on the differences in sources and composition of ambient PM2.5 in two Southern Ontario locations

Abstract

PM2.5 was sampled over a seven-year period (2013–2019) at two locations ∼50 km apart in Southern Ontario (concurrently for five years: 2015–2019). One is a heavily industrialized site (Hamilton), while the other was a rural site (Simcoe). To assess the impact of industrialization on the composition and sources of PM affecting air quality in these two locations, positive matrix factorization coupled with dispersion normalization (DN-PMF) was used to identify six and eight factors at Simcoe and Hamilton, respectively. The Simcoe factors in order of diminishing PM mass contribution were: particulate sulphate (pSO4), secondary organic aerosol (SOA), crustal matter, particulate nitrate (pNO3), biomass burning, and vehicular emissions. At Hamilton, the effects of industrialization were observed by the ∼36% higher average ambient PM2.5 concentration for the study period as well as the presence of factors unique to metallurgy, i.e., coking and steelmaking, compared to Simcoe. The coking and steelmaking factors contributed ∼15% to the PM mass at Hamilton. Seasonal variants of appropriate nonparametric trend tests with the associated slopes (Sen's) were used to assess statistically significant changes in the factor contributions to PM2.5 over time. Specifically at Hamilton, a significant decline in PM contributions was noted for coking (−0.03 μg/m³/yr or −4.1%/yr) while steelmaking showed no statistically significant decline over the study period. Other factors at Hamilton that showed statistically significant declines over the study period were: pSO4 (−0.27 μg/m³/yr or −12.6%/yr), biomass burning (−0.05 μg/m³/yr or −9.02%/yr), crustal matter (−0.03 μg/m³/yr or −5.28%/yr). These factors mainly accounted for the significant decline in PM2.5 over the study period (−0.35 μg/m³/yr or −4.24%/yr). This work shows the importance of long-term monitoring in assessing the unique contributions and temporal changes of industrialization on air quality in Ontario and similarly affected locations.