Effect of Gonadal Protection on Image Quality in Frontal Hip Radiography

Abstract

In recent years, there has been a growing movement in Western countries toward the abolition of gonadal protection during radiography. The reasons for this recommendation are that there are few reports of increased risk of genetic effects, that the ovarian dose is not due to direct X-rays but due to internally scattered X-rays that cannot be shielded, and that the presence of gonadal protection may adversely affect the automatic exposure control mechanism and may mask important findings. In addition, the gonadal protection is a large high absorber of X-rays, and its presence in the irradiation field may have some effect on image quality, but the effect of the gonadal protection on image quality has not been clarified. In addition, after the abolition of gonadal protection, the optimal irradiation field setting is expected to become even more important to avoid unnecessary exposure. In this study, we investigated the effect of gonadal protection on image quality in frontal hip radiographs of adults with different radiation qualities and clarified the image quality under conditions in which the irradiation field is appropriately narrowed. Frontal hip radiographs were taken using a human phantom as the subject, and the image quality of the femoral head was evaluated. Two irradiation fields were used: (a) 14×17 inch field and (b) an appropriate field (11.6×15 inch) that does not impair the reference line and image information necessary for reading hip joint images. The imaging tube voltage was set at 70 kV, and conditions for adding a copper filter were also considered. The incident surface air kerma was set to 1.25 mGy. The incident surface dose at this time was sufficiently lower than the diagnostic reference level (2.5 mGy) in Japan and was judged to be appropriate for imaging using an indirect conversion flat panel detector. The image quality evaluation item was the signal difference to noise ratio (SdNR) including scatterers. The SdNR decreased by 4.6% when a gonadal shield was placed, indicating that the gonadal shield reduced image quality. When the irradiation field size was appropriately narrowed down, SdNR slightly increased or decreased depending on the quality of the imaging material, but the change was small compared to the change in SdNR with and without the gonadal protection shield. The results of this study confirm that the elimination of gonadal protection in hip radiography has significant advantages, such as reducing unnecessary X-ray exposure while ensuring image quality, when the irradiation field is set appropriately.