Effect of flaw orientation on magnetic flux leakage and remote field eddy current inspection of small diameter steel tubes

Abstract

ABSTRACT This paper presents effect of flaw orientation on magnetic flux leakage (MFL) and remote field eddy current (RFEC) inspection of small diameter (19.05-mm outer diameter, OD and 2.77-mm wall thickness, WT) seamless low carbon steel tubes. Artificial electro-discharge machined (EDM) notches in three carbon steel Tubes A (orientations from 0° to 90° in steps of 10° and 50% WT depth), B (70° orientation and depths from 10% WT to 100% WT in steps of 10% WT) and C (50° orientation and depths from 10% WT to 60% WT in steps of 10% WT) were used to investigate the detectability of notches with different orientations and depths. Studies on different notch orientations reveal that RFEC technique detected all the notches with good signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), while MFL technique detected the notches with orientations from 40° to 90°. The effect of notch orientation is observed more in MFL technique as compared to RFEC technique. Further, the effects of scanning speed and notch depth for the detection of oriented notches were studied. Studies reveal that the effect of scanning speed is also more (40 times) dominant in MFL technique as compared to RFEC technique. Studies also reveal that the scanning effect is again dependent upon the notch depth. For 70° oriented notches, MFL technique is found to be more sensitive to notch depth as compared to RFEC technique. For 50° oriented notches, RFEC technique is found to be more sensitive to notch depth as compared to MFL technique.