Economic implications of forecasting electricity generation from variable renewable energy sources

Abstract

Short-term forecasting of electricity generation from variable renewable energy sources is not an end in itself but should provide some net benefit to its user. In the case of electricity trading, which is in the focus of this paper, the benefit can be quantified in terms of an improved economic outcome. Although some effort has been made to evaluate and to improve the profitability of electricity forecasts, the understanding of the underlying effects has remained incomplete so far. In this paper, we develop a more comprehensive theoretical framework of the connection between the statistical and the economic properties of day-ahead electricity forecasts. We find that, apart from the accuracy and the bias, which have already been extensively researched, the correlation between the forecast errors and the market price spread determines the economic implications - a phenomenon which we refer to as ‘correlation effect’. Our analysis is completed by a case study on solar electricity forecasting in Germany which illustrates the relevance and the limits of both our theoretical framework and the correlation effect. • The economics of short-term electricity forecasts are studied analytically and empirically. • The value and the risk of forecast-based electricity trading are evaluated. • We find that the economics depend on the correlation of forecast errors with prices. • Hence, the most accurate forecast is not necessarily the most accurate.