Ecological characterisation of urban ponds in the Netherlands: a study based on data collected by volunteers

Abstract

Blue space in the urban environment can positively contribute to public health and well-being. Many urban freshwater systems, however, are exposed to anthropogenic stressors, resulting in deteriorated water quality and biodiversity. Private garden ponds are essential elements of this blue space but little is known about their water quality since they are not monitored by water professionals. The Dutch citizen science initiative Waterdiertjes.nl focusses on biological water quality assessment using macroinvertebrates and launched a campaign to investigate garden ponds in 2021. The campaign yielded macroinvertebrate recordings in 60 garden ponds and limited additional information on dimensions, and presence of water vegetation and fish. Volunteers also investigated 92 public urban ponds in 2021. Combining both data allowed for evaluation of the similarity between both pond types. Analyses were also performed to discover the importance of pond dimensions and presence of aquatic vegetation or fish for the macroinvertebrate biodiversity and water quality. Multivariate analyses showed a considerable overlap in macroinvertebrate community composition between garden and public urban ponds. Results showed high variability in taxon richness, total macroinvertebrate density and water quality scores A significant, nonlinear relation was observed between pond depth and macroinvertebrate taxon richness with the highest richness at a depth of 0.5-1m. Submerged vegetation correlated significantly with taxon richness with little vegetation having the lowest richness. Presence of fish or floating vegetation was not significantly related to taxon richness, total density and water quality scores possibly due to unnatural conditions that underlie in garden ponds. Since water professionals and academic scientists do not monitor garden ponds, citizen science may provide valuable data on water quality and biodiversity in these waters. The present initiative showed that volunteers can successfully monitor understudied ecosystems and gather data on temporal and spatial scales complementary to professional data that lead to new (ecological) insights.