Dynamics of Cu isotope fractionation during the reactions of pyrite with Cu(I)-bearing hydrothermal fluids

Abstract

Experimental investigation of the fractionation behavior of Cu isotopes during the replacement of pyrite by Cu-bearing sulfides (chalcopyrite, bornite, and chalcocite) was conducted under hydrothermal conditions. At the initial stages of the replacement reaction, small mounds of product formed on the pyrite surface; these mounds then grew and coalesced, progressively covering the pyrite grains as the reaction proceeded. Chalcopyrite, bornite, and chalcocite formed sequential monomineralic zones from the pyrite reaction front towards the solution. During the early stage of the reaction, Cu isotope fractionation between the solids and the aqueous solution (Δ65Cusolid-aqueous, Δ65Cusolid-aqueous = δ65Cusolid – δ65Cuaqueous) was approximately –0.6 ‰, similar to the calculated equilibrium Cu isotope fractionation factors between Cu-bearing sulfides (chalcopyrite, bornite, and chalcocite) and CuCl2–. However, the Δ65Cusolid-aqueous moved progressively further from equilibrium with prolonged reaction time, with fractionation factors ranging from approximately –0.6 ‰ to –1.2 ‰. We found that significant fractionation of Cu isotopes between the solid products and aqueous solution was mainly controlled by the amount of chalcopyrite that formed in the product layers. We interpret that the Δ65Cusolid-aqueous was controlled by the diffusion of aqueous Cu(I) species among the product layers and the changes in Cu redox state during the precipitation of chalcopyrite. These results imply that the δ65Cu values measured in sulfides from low-temperature hydrothermal deposits may be controlled by the local chemistry of the fluids in product layers that precipitate sulfides. This study highlights the importance of local fluid characteristics, such as redox conditions, metal speciation, and diffusion, in controlling isotope fractionation pathways during non-equilibrium mineral replacement.