Dynamic evolution of marine productivity, redox, and biogeochemical cycling track local and global controls on Cryogenian sea-level change

Abstract

The Cryogenian period of the Neoproterozoic was marked by two Snowball Earth glaciations that bookended a non-glacial interval that lasted roughly 10 million years. The break-up of Rodinia in the early Neoproterozoic gave rise to numerous rift basins whose time-varying redox dynamics, linked to marine productivity and biogeochemical cycling, were likely controlled by varying degrees of basin restriction in response to sea-level change. Those drivers were associated with both global glaciations (Sturtian deglaciation and the possibly early onset of the Marinoan) and local tectonics (regional basin uplift/subsidence). To explore these relationships, we focus on the Datangpo Formation, an exceptional shale sequence deposited in a marginal rift basin in South China. The Datangpo succession comprises lower organic-rich black shales and upper organic-lean gray shales/siltstones. As elucidated by our integrated data, the former were deposited in H2S-rich, deep-water settings underlying highly productive surface waters. We attribute this productivity to elevated nutrient supplies replenished from the open ocean following a sea-level rise, as augmented by high terrestrial input of phosphate in the wake of the Sturtian deglaciation. By contrast, the gray shales/siltstones were associated with relatively shallow deposition in an oxic/suboxic water column with suppressed primary production. The major driver of this dramatic shift in water chemistry may lie with a greater extent of basin isolation and the corresponding reduction in nutrient fluxes from the global ocean due to a significant sea-level fall—possibly linked to regional basin uplift. At this time, the basin experienced an elevated influx of detrital clays and organic material, perhaps triggered by lower sea level. Surprisingly, we found that euxinic conditions prevailed in the water column for a substantial period following the onset of more isolated conditions. This relationship can be attributed to redox-dependent phosphorus cycling. Specifically, H2S-replete conditions facilitated regeneration of bioavailable phosphorus, initiating a positive feedback that allowed the persistence of anoxic waters. This study advances our understanding of nutrient cycling and biogeochemical evolution during the Cryogenian under the influence of large-scale sea-level fluctuations and associated time-varying connectivity to the open ocean that must have been common in many basins at this time. Furthermore, our study sheds novel light on the iron proxy and early sulfur cycling. Almost all of the terrestrial silicate-bound iron was likely converted into highly reactive phases due to strong chemical weathering, while sulfur data revealed isotopic stratification in the wake of Sturtian deglaciation, with important messages for interpretations of analogous data in the aftermath of other climate upheavals in Earth history.