Does Physician Gender and Gender Composition of Clinical Teams Affect Guideline Concordance and Patient Outcomes in Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest?

Abstract

Objective: Prior literature has shown improved outcomes in morbidity and mortality for admitted patients cared for by female physicians. One theory is that female physicians adhere closely to guideline recommendations. We sought to determine whether patients who have out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) experience more guideline-concordant postcardiac arrest care and potentially better outcomes based on the gender of their treating physician and gender distribution of the treatment teams. Methods: This study is a retrospective cohort study from the Colorado Cardiac Arrest Registry, local registry of OHCA patients treated at one academic urban tertiary care hospital. We analyzed adult OHCA patients who survived to hospital admission but were comatose. Patient demographic data and arrest characteristics were abstracted for subjects, and the gender of the provider was abstracted from the medical record. Results: Patients were admitted by a female attending in 28.5% of the cohort. The difference in guideline-concordant care between male and female providers was not significant. No statistical difference was found between all-male or mixed gender teams in adherence to guideline-concordant care. No patient was cared for by an all-female team. Neither gender of the admitting physician nor gender of the physician who led the family meeting to discuss prognosis was associated with a survival difference. Conclusions: Prior literature has described differences in outcome based on gender of the treating physician. Our analysis targeted a similar question in a cohort of OHCA patients with survival to hospital admission. We determined that there was no difference in postcardiac arrest guideline concordance and survival to hospital discharge based on treating physician gender. This finding differs from the prior literature and supports the importance of diverse clinical teams in medicine.