Does enemy‐free space for eggs contribute to a leaf beetle’s oviposition preference for a nutritionally inferior host plant?

Abstract

Summary Natural enemies are likely to influence the interactions between herbivorous insects and their host plants. In particular, selection exerted by natural enemies could favour host‐plant switches and cause, or maintain, oviposition preference for a host species that is nutritionally inferior to another acceptable host. In a previous study, it was shown that larvae of the leaf beetle Oreina elongata perform better on Adenostyles alliariae (Asteraceae) than on Cirsium spinosissimum (Asteraceae). Moreover, A. alliariae provides larval and adult beetles with sequestrable chemical defences. However, in the field, egg densities are much higher on C. spinosissimum than on adjacent A. alliariae. In this study, it was investigated whether this oviposition pattern could be maintained by C. spinosissimum, providing the eggs of O. elongata with better protection from natural enemies. In a field experiment, the survival of eggs was quantified on plants of each of the two species, with and without enemy exclusion. Egg survival was equal for both host species when enemies were excluded from the plants, but it was higher on C. spinosissimum than on A. alliariae when enemies were allowed to the plants. It was also experimentally tested whether the higher egg densities observed in the field on C. spinosissimum are actually due to oviposition preference by the beetle. In a no‐choice test, females laid more eggs on C. spinosissimum than on A. alliariae. It can thus be confirmed that C. spinosissimum is really preferred for oviposition and it is concluded that this preference is likely to be maintained, at least partly, by a higher egg survival on C. spinosissimum due to enemy‐free space provided by this host plant.