Distinguishing Iron Deficiency Anemia From Beta-Thalassemia Trait: Comparative Analysis of CRUISE Index and Other Traditional Diagnostic Indices.

Abstract

Introduction Iron deficiency anemia and beta-thalassemia trait are two common and important differentials of microcytic hypochromic anemia. Various discrimination indices using two or more common complete blood cell count (CBC) parameters have been used to distinguish between the two since1973. Recently, a new discriminant index, the CRUISE index, was proposed in the year 2019. The efficacy of various older indices along with the CRUISE index was evaluated for patients in our geographical area. Materials and method Ours was a laboratory-based, cross-sectional study where 100 patients, based on inclusion and exclusion criteria, with microcytic hypochromic anemia were evaluated for CBC parameters along with serum ferritin and hemoglobin-high performance liquid chromatography (Hb HPLC). A total of eight discrimination indices namely, Mentzer, Srivastava, Shine & Lal, Green & King, RDWI, England & Fraser, Kerman I and CRUISE index were used and evaluated for their diagnostic efficacy using different statistical parameters. ROC curves were obtained and a new cut-off value was proposed for our population. Data was analysed using Microsoft Excel (Microsoft® Corp., Redmond, WA, USA) and SPSS v29.0.2.0 (20) (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA). Results Out of the total 100 cases, 39 were beta-thalassemia trait and 61 were iron deficiency anemia cases. The average age was 36.7 (±12.7 SD) years. Among the 73 females, 43 were diagnosed as iron deficiency anemia (IDA) and 30 as beta-thalassemia trait (BTT) cases. Among the 27 males, 18 were diagnosed as IDA and nine as BTT cases. The mean values were significantly lower in IDA patients for mean corpuscular volume (MCV) (p=.008), mean corpuscular haemoglobin (MCH) (p=.003), and mean corpuscular haemoglobin concentration (MCHC) (p=.003) and significantly higher for red cell distribution width (RDW) (p=.020). The mean ferritin levels in cases of IDA were 7.61 (±3.75) mcg/L and in BTT were 87.09 (±66.77 SD) mcg/L. The mean HbA2 levels in IDA cases were 2.75% (±0.41% SD) and BTT cases were 5.57% (±0.73% SD). CRUISEindex revealed the highest AUC (0.934), YI (76.21) and accuracy (90%) followed by the Mentzer index with a diagnostic accuracy of 81%. Shine & Lal index revealed the lowest AUC (0.710), YI (3.28) and accuracy (41%). Conclusion CRUISE index, which was recently proposed, was ranked 1st in terms of AUC, YI, and accuracy and was considered 2nd best in terms of sensitivity for differentially diagnosing the two conditions. Mentzer index, a commonly used index, also revealed a high diagnostic accuracy in our study for differentiating BTT from IDA. CRUISE index being a novel index, more research work needs to be carried out in various other geographical setups to evaluate the efficacy of this index.