Distinction between low-barrier hydrogen bond and ordinary hydrogen bond: a case study of varying nature of charge assisted hydrogen bonds of diglycine perchlorate crystal

Abstract

Hydrogen bonding is a complex phenomenon that is a resultant of many energy components like the electrostatic, dispersive, covalent, charge cloud overlap repulsion etc, nature of hydrogen bond (H-bond) depends on which of these components play a dominant role. Low barrier hydrogen bond (LBHB) constitutes a special category of hydrogen bonds characterized by near delocalization of proton between donor and acceptor groups of the H- bond unlike an ordinary hydrogen bond (OHB) having proton clearly localized near the donor group. The significance of LBHBs in macromolecular interactions has been highly controversial, despite may attempts the existence and potential importance of protein LBHBs remains debatable. In order to answer questions like whether or not a distinct class of LBHBs exists and if they do exist under what conditions they are formed and how do they behave differently from OHBs, a detailed study of H-bonding in Diglycine Perchlorate (DGPCl) crystal containing five unique hydrogen bonded glycinium-glycine pairs is undertaken. All O-H–O bonds of DGPCl are between the carboxyl (-COOH) and carboxylate (-COO−) groups with slightly different electron distributions resulting in observable variations in the H-bond geometries, this is an indication of varying strength of these short strong H-bonds. It is found that LBHB nature of the five O-H—O bonds between glycinium-glycine pairs (P1-P5) varies as P1 < P4 < P2 < P3 < P5. This study gives an experimental evidence of the existence of LBHBs and demonstrates that the behaviour of LBHBs is very different from that of strong OHBs.