Distal Scaphoid Excision for Chronic and Nonchronic Scaphoid Fracture Nonunion

Abstract

PurposeThe indications for distal scaphoid excision are limited to localized wrist arthritis surrounding the scaphoid as a result of scaphoid nonunion advanced collapse or scapho-trapezio-trapezoid (STT) joint arthritis. The procedure historically has led to relief of symptoms and improvement in strength. Our aim was to examine the outcomes of this procedure in patients with scaphoid fracture nonunion. MethodsThis is a single-center retrospective case series of 12 consecutive patients who underwent distal scaphoid excision after scaphoid fracture nonunion. Patients were divided into two groups based on nonunion chronicity: chronic (more than a year) and non-chronic (less than a year). Clinical and radiographic data were examined using descriptive statistics. ResultsOur cohort consisted of 12 patients, 10 men (83%) and 2 women (17%), with a mean age 37.6±13.6 years. Eight patients had a chronic scaphoid fracture nonunion (6 had a neglected scaphoid fracture and 2 had a nonunion after scaphoid open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) with bone graft) and 4 patients had non-chronic fracture non-union (2 had failed cast treatment and 2 had nonunion after scaphoid ORIF with bone graft). Pre-operatively, all patients complained of pain and 4 had numbness (all in chronic group). After an average 21 weeks post-operatively, 7 patients (58%) reported continued pain. Two patients reported ulnar side pain, one underwent arthroscopic synovectomy. All patients who started with normal radiolunate angle continued to have normal angle, whereas patients who had DISI prior to surgery persisted after surgery except for a patient who underwent midcarpal fusion and had their radiolunate angle corrected. ConclusionsDistal scaphoid excision is an effective procedure for carefully selected patients with periscaphoid wrist arthrosis. Patients with recent scaphoid fracture that failed treatment may also be treated with distal scaphoid resection.